Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Curse of Kosi: Man Made Calamities and Disaster Management
Curse of Kosi: Man Made Calamities and Disaster Management
Troubled Galaxy Destroyed Dreams: Chapter 56
Palash Biswas
http://troubledgalaxydetroyeddreams.blogspot.com/
Bihar floods: A man-made disaster
The devastating floods in Bihar, caused by a breach in the Kosi barrage, have left many dead and more than 30 lakhs displaced. But the extent of the floods could have been lessened had the administration been alert to the impending tragedy..
http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=140554
Koshi River
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
This article or section needs copy editing for grammar, style, cohesion, tone or spelling.
You can assist by editing it now. A how-to guide is available. (August 2008)
The Kosi River, called Koshi in Nepal (Nepali: कोशी नदी), is a transboundary river between Nepal and India, and is one of the largest tributaries of the Ganga. The river, along with its tributaries, drains a total area of 69,300 km2 (26,800 sq mi) up to its confluence with the Ganga in India (29,400 km2/11,400 sq mi in China, 30,700 km2/11,900 sq mi in Nepal and 9,200 km2/3,600 sq mi in India). The watershed also includes part of Tibet, such as the Mount Everest region, and the eastern third of Nepal. The river basin is surrounded by the ridges separating it from the Brahmaputra in the north, the Gandaki in the west, the Mahananda in the east, and by the Ganga in the south. The river is joined by major tributaries, approximately 48 km (30 mi) north of the Indo-Nepal border, breaking into more than twelve distinct channels with shifting courses due to flooding.[1][2] Kamlā, Bāghmati (Kareh) and Budhi Gandak are major tributaries of Koshi in India, besides minor tributaries like Bhutahi Balān.[3][4] Over the last 250 years, the Kosi River has shifted its course over 120 kilometres (75 mi) from east to west.[5] and the unstable nature of the river is attributed to the heavy silt which it carries during the monsoon season. Flooding in India has extreme effects. India is second in the world after Bangladesh in deaths due to flooding, accounting for one fifth of global flooding deaths. The Kosi River (The Sorrow of Bihar) is one of two major tributaries, the other river being Gandak, draining the plains of north Bihar, the most flood-prone area of India[6]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koshi_River
BBC News Army Engineers to help repair barrage on Kosi
SINDH TODAY, Pakistan - 2 hours ago
‘Regarding the repair of the Bheem Barrage on river Kosi where the breach took place, the Centre has offered the help of Army Engineers and the BRO,’ said ...
Bihar govt's negligent attitude responsible for floods: Minister Business Standard
SC declines hearing on PIL for repair of Kosi river embankment Indlaw.com
Indian flood victims hunker down in camps International Herald Tribune
Reuters - Thaindian.com
all 1,921 news articles »
TopNews Don't blame Nepal but Bihar govt for flood: Lalu
Economic Times, India - 47 minutes ago
In the backdrop of media reports that Nepal released thousands of cusecs of water in Kosi, he said it was the state's unpreparedness to tackle the flood ...
Kosi will become an election issue: Lalu Zee News
CM asks Lalu not to demoralize officials Times of India
Lalu prays to Kosi to curb its destructive powers IBNLive.com
The Statesman - Press Trust of India
all 193 news articles »
Chipko movement
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Villagers surrounding a tree to stop them from being felled
The Chipko movement (literally "to stick" in Hindi) was a group of female peasants in the Uttaranchal region of India who acted to prevent the cutting of trees and reclaim their traditional forest rights that were threatened by the contractor system of the state Forest Department. The movement began in Chamoli district in 1973 and spread throughout the Uttaranchal Himalayas by the end of the decade. In Tehri district, Chipko activists would go on to protest limestone mining in the Dehra Dun hills in the 1980s as well as the Tehri dam, before founding the Beej Bachao Andolan or Save the Seeds movement that continues to the present day. In Kumaon region, Chipko took on a more radical hue, combining with the general movement for a separate Uttaranchal state.[1]
One of Chipko's most salient features was the mass participation of women villagers.[2] As the backbone of Uttaranchal's agrarian economy, women were most directly affected by environmental degradation and deforestation, and thus connected the issues most easily. How much this participation impacted or derived from the ideology of Chipko, has been fiercely debated in academic circles.[3] Despite this, both female and male activists did play pivotal roles in the movement including Gaura Devi, Sudesha Devi, Bachni Devi, Chandi Prasad Bhatt, Sundarlal Bahuguna, Govind Singh Rawat, Dhoom Singh Negi and Shamsher Singh Bisht.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chipko_movement
Kosi's tragedy: Blunder after blunder
Himanshu Thakkar
September 01, 2008
The Kosi river basin in Bihar is facing its biggest ever flood disaster ever, and that disaster has come about completely due to the neglect of the Government of India and the government of Bihar. It is a manmade disaster which could have been avoided.
Amidst the din of 'national calamity, catastrophe and river changing course', about two million people are facing forced submergence and displacement. The governments of India and Bihar are going about the relief work as if it is a favour they are doing for the people. That favour is being doled out in a totally haphazard, unplanned, callous way.
For immediate relief it is important that those being brought out from the waterlogged areas be given cooked food for at least two days. There should be planned settlements for such people, with arrangements for shelter, fuel, fodder, medicines, hygiene etc, as they are likely to have to stay at these places for up to two months. The affected people need not be considered as victims as is the case now, but should be involved in the whole exercise. Two million people cannot be resettled by outsiders. And in the comparatively lax law and order situation of Bihar, the responsibility of the state and the Centre increases considerably in ensuring dignified relief and resettlement.
In this effort, another very important aspect seems to be totally ignored. Most (about 85 per cent) of the 1.5 lakh cusecs (cubic feet per second) of Kosi water is flowing through the breach in the embankment that started with a small, few metres-wide breach on the eastern side, 12.9 km upstream of the barrage in the afternoon of August 18. This water is flowing through three of the 15 old streams of the Kosi river, namely Sursar, Mirchaiya and Belhi, says Dinesh Kumar Mishra, possibly the most well-informed person in India on Bihar floods, from his camp at Khagaria. This water is entering an area that does not have the capacity drain so much water
http://in.rediff.com/news/2008/sep/01guest.htm
The Centre has accused Nitish Kumar government of not sending a scheme for works to be executed on the damaged dams on the Nepal section of the Kosi river. But t The Centre has assured all possible assistance to the Bihar government in the wake of the ongoing flood relief and rescue operations and a high level Central team has offered the help of Army engineers and the Border Roads Organisation for repair of the Bheem barrage on river Kosi where the breach took place.
Too late!
Ex chief minister of Bihar, the high profile railway Minister of India also sheds crocodile Tears in sympathy and vomits venom against the government of Bihar! As if the center has no responsibility at all.
In Bengal, People may remember the words of the Fire Brand Opposition Leader Ms Mamata Bannerjee that Floods in Bengal are Man Made!
Given the fact the Kosi has a track record of flowing in excess of 9 lakh cusecs, the Bihar government is indeed worried that a monumental effort will have to be put in to rescue the people. “We will have to rescue more than 10 lakh people in relief camps. And we will have to keep them for more than 6 months as it will take time to plug the breach. More significantly, the flow of the Kosi will have to shift to its original course and all this will take time,” the chief minister said.
At least 5 districts of North Bihar including Supaul and Madhepura are in the spate of Kosi river following the breach in its eastern afflux embankment at Kusaha in Nepal . The breach was caused on 18 August but the breach ever since has been widening under the pressure of the turbulent Kosi.. Obviously, the river has opened a new channel and meandering on a course with the potential to cause incalculable damage to human population.
Meanwhile, The flood situation in Assam continued to be critical on Wednesday with Brahmaputra river and its tributaries creating havoc in the state, claiming 15 lives and rendering several thousands homeless. Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi accompanied by senior officials made an aerial survey of Majuli, Asia's largest river island, which submerged under the flood waters, official sources said on Wednesday.
It is just the beginning!
We are so habitual to see and bypass the calamities every year. UP, Bihar, Bengal, Assam and elsewhere, the Indigenous Communities have to face flood every year. The Capital of India is not spared also.
A lot of people say its God’s doing, but God is no more responsible for the destruction caused by earthquakes, flooding or tornados than a weatherman is responsible for the damage done by a typhoon that he forecasts. Many defenseless people live in harm’s way, in places where natural or man-made disasters are very likely to strike. Some disasters are at least partially man-made.
Take for example the residents of New Orleans, the hurricane that flooded the city, or the mudslides of Venezuela and others, natural things such as wind and rain turned deadly largely because of human environmental mistakes, shoddy engineering, flawed planning and unheeded warnings.
Can we blame God for that? Greedy humans must bear some of the blame for the calamities that people experience.
Every time the floods kill the Ingenious Communities and the majority people living under poverty Line!
The Human scape of Kosi Area is to be analysed to understand the phenomenon. Just for a clue, we may witness the Slums in Kolkata, New Delhi and Mumbai are always inundated! Yes, the Posh areas are also effected. But it is the marginal, poor and indigenous class which is devastated losing life, livelihood and production system.
Just understand the timing! It is Festival Time in India. Ramdan is underway. Puja Countdown has just begun. It has to be followed by Diwali and Ganapati utsav. This is shopping time and the indigenous communities are out of Market, out of production, out of livelihood. They have to be rescued. They have to be sheltered and fed on. It is the same chronology every year!
They brand it as Natural Calamity!
Is it?
Calamityis defined well.
An event that brings terrible loss, lasting distress, or severe affliction; a disaster: A hurricane would be a calamity for this low-lying coastal region!
Dire distress resulting from loss or tragedy!
Noun 1. calamity - an event resulting in great loss and misfortune; "the whole city was affected by the irremediable calamity"; "the earthquake was a disaster"
catastrophe, tragedy, cataclysm, disaster
misfortune, bad luck - unnecessary and unforeseen trouble resulting from an unfortunate event
act of God, force majeure, inevitable accident, unavoidable casualty, vis major - a natural and unavoidable catastrophe that interrupts the expected course of events; "he discovered that his house was not insured against acts of God"
apocalypse - a cosmic cataclysm in which God destroys the ruling powers of evil
famine - a severe shortage of food (as through crop failure) resulting in violent hunger and starvation and death
kiss of death - something that is ruinous; "if this were known it would be the kiss of death for my political career"
meltdown - a disaster comparable to a nuclear meltdown; "there is little likelihood of a meltdown comparable to the American banking collapse in March 1933"
plague - any large scale calamity (especially when thought to be sent by God)
visitation - any disaster or catastrophe; "a visitation of the plague"
tidal wave - an unusual (and often destructive) rise of water along the seashore caused by a storm or a combination of wind and high tide
tsunami - a cataclysm resulting from a destructive sea wave caused by an earthquake or volcanic eruption; "a colossal tsunami destroyed the Minoan civilization in minutes"
“Water shortage is one of the most pressing problems of the country as our resources are fast depleting. Besides, there is a large-scale pollution of water resources which needs to be checked. We must learn to keep our air, water and soil clean.” This was stated by environmentalist and Chipko Movement exponent Sunderlal Bahuguna at Guru Nanak Dev University during the Bhagat Puran Singh Memorial National Seminar, jointly organised by the All India Pingalwara Charitable Society and the University.
Bahuguna said adequate steps should be taken for recharging the groundwater. He also laid emphasis on checking the population explosion. “If steps are not taken to check the decreasing level of the water table, Punjab and other states would suffer,” said Bahuguna.
We know the rivers very well. We know the landscape. We know the Human scape.
It is quite Nonsense to blame the Nature!
Nature has it`s own law. Nature never breaks it`s laws! Day and Night, BIO Cycle, Weather and season, Eclipses, Tides .. everything continue mathematically accurate. So that NASA is capable to launch Space dominance Campaign. We may calculate the Time and Distance and we may get them accordingly. So we dream to colonise Moon and Mars!
Just take the Earth Quake prone Japan!
Just consider the cases of Hurricanes, Twister, Tornado in Americas!
How do they manage the Disaster there?
How do they execute Evacuation?
How do they successfully complete Rescue Operation ?
We have the Man Power.
We have the Technology!
We have the resources!
We have the Administrative network from Centre to the Panchayat!
We have also a system of Disaster management!
But everything fails!
I dare to claim that the failure is deliberate and it benefits the Ruling Hegemony and the market forces. Thus, the genuine attempt to address the calamities are absent every time!
We are so called civilised people who tend to disturb the Nature! We are safe in our heaven! Only the Poor and the Indigenous People have to encounter the Fury of nature!
Who created the Big dams?
Who are responsible for Deforestation all over the Himalayan region causing Land Slide and Avalanches, Floods and Disaster!
We addressed the issues during seventies with Chipko Movement led by Sunderlal Bahuguna! Ladies of Chamoli in Uttarkhand introduced chipko, the most relevant Ecological movement in India! We protested the Tehri dam and opposed every attempt to disturb the natural flow of the rivers!
In 1978, India suffered heavily while Floods innundated the Palins upto ganga sagar just because the natural flow of the Ganges was blocked in Gangotri. I had been there and reported for Dharmayug!
They created Big Dams without considering the climate, weather, ecology, human scape..anything. Narmada Bachao Andolan is trying its best. But the state power is always used against the indigenous people uprooting and killing them. Since Bhakhra Nangal and Rihand dam the story continues!
They create the Big Dams and Embankment without caring to manage them properly. Experts and Engineers base in the Capital cities enjoying the Time and Place in every possible ways. They are often tempted to create artificial calamities to defend the interest of the Ruling class and the Market forces. On the other hand , the dams and embankments have to be overseen by manual labour stripped off technical expertise!
We are Super Power to be! We are shining! We claim to be the developed nationality. But we have to get the goal with the annihilation and mass displacement of the Indigenous communities. We have to sell the Natural Resources. We handover everything! The society with inherent inequality and injustice manipulates the Politics to get expected favour and results!
Have you read Phanishwar Nath RENU? Maila Aanchal!
Phanishwar Nath 'Renu'
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Phanishwar Nath 'Renu' (???????? ??? ????) (March 4, 1921 – April 11, 1977) was one of the greatest writers of modern Hindi literature in the post-Premchand era. He is the author of Maila Anchal', which after Premchand's Godan, is regarded as the most significant Hindi novel.[1]
Phanishwar Nath 'Renu' is most known for promoting the voice of the contemporary rural India through the genre of 'Aanchalik Upanyas' (Regional Story), and is placed amongst the pioneering Hindi writers who brought regional voices into the mainstream Hindi literature.
His short story Maare Gaye Gulfam was adapted into a film Teesri Kasam by Basu Bhattacharya (produced by the poet-lyricist Shailendra) in 1966 for which he also wrote the dialogues. Later his short story 'Panchlight' (Patromax) was made into a TV short film.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phanishwar_Nath_'Renu'
Maila Aanchal by Phanishwar Nath Renu
Buzz up! ShareThisMar 22 2007 | Views 1800 | Comments (5)
Tags: Book Review Hindi
Renu's Maila Anchal is one of the finest novels ever written in Hindi. The landscape of Bihar, the caste divide, Indian independence and changes in its aftermath, Maithali folklores and poems, the multiple love stories painted on a canvas with highly perceptive descriptions of village life make it one of the most important novels written in and about rural India.
The novel was first published in early 1950s, in the post Prem Chand era, at a time when young, independent India was trying to redefine its identity as a Nation. The novel is set in Bihar, and incorporates the regional contexts and references into its theme, making it into a perfect example of Anchalik Upanyaas (Regional Novel).
A short synopsis of the story reads as follows (I won't serve you details or surprises, just the bare bones, no soul, no flesh): Tehsildaar babu, by virtue of his position in administration has acquired large tracts of land, and turned into a Zamindaar (landlord) himself. He has a daughter by name of Kamla, who suffers from fits. Doctor babu (Dagdar babu) has left his city life to work in these hinterlands. This is the realm where Malaria, Kalazar and numerous such epidemics run havoc, where people trust tantriks and pandits (witches and priests) more than they trust medicine, where poverty itself is the biggest disease affecting people, and besides lack of basic amenities, people lack education and faith in government as well as doctor himself. Based on true life story of Dr Alakh Niranjan, who was alive (and 100 years old) in 2003, the doctor babu takes pains to fight disease and disbelief, in his battle for making people survive their ailments and superstitions. Kamla, who is his patient, falls in love with him.
Lakshmi lives on the Matth (a kind of monastery), serving old Mahanth (a priest) (a scandalous relationship). The Mahanth has a servant, who bears all insult from his master, and eventhough he was of low birth, is admitted into the Matth, as he is adept at playing the Khanjira (a musical instrument). A freedom fighter, S (I forget his name), comes in contact with Lakshmi, and is attracted to her. After Mahanth's death, the servant assumes office with help of Lakshmi, and because of her position, she is the butt of several people's lust, till she gives up her position in Matth.
There are a whole bunch of characters who get involved in caste based politics. Apart from S, who is a strict Gandhian (and makes speeches in pure Hindi, that most villagers admire, but never understand), there is a dwarf, who has had correspondence with Mahatma Gandhi himself and who after Mahatma's death, wanes away like a celebrated candle of dark hours flickers away unnoticed, once electricity connection is restored. There are the village hooligans who are lured by Communist party. There is division of ranks between different castes and groups, the divisions become harsher as politics promises power and money, and if you wonder about caste based politics, its roots and consequences, Maila Aanchal has a perfect script for tracing its roots. It also, in a manner of great story tellers, where the events speaks for themselves, shed light on how Gandhi was revered in even these remotest villages and how his death was mourned by most who did not know what difference becoming "free" would to make to them. For them the simile of being like a free bird means nothing, for they are like wingless birds who know not what wonders a flight entails, what sceneries lie beyond the horizons. The events reveal how Gandhians and idealists lost hope and direction after Independent India thrust itself into games of corruption and caste-based politics. The events prescribe the socio-economic condition of the villagers, the unequal sharing of crops, the inherited hierarchy of caste and money, and the crux of family values.
Be it gossip or folklores, songs of tribals or cures by the Doctor; be it drama (nautanki) enacted on stage or the Akhara fights (the wrestling matches); be it dresses and ornaments of womenfolk or the idealism and corruption of men; be it the bhajans (hymns) in Matth or the lust of men who sought Lakshmi; be it the harvesting season or description of monsoon rain; Renu presents a masterpiece where each description comes with a perspective and perception as keen and humane as of Tolstoy, as astute as of Maugham and Lawrence.
If Renu were an author in any other language, in other country or tongue, he would have managed to be read and celebrated a million times better than he is by us Hindi speaking Indians. He shares this fate with Prem Chand, Ramdhari Singh Dinkar, Bachchan, Dharamveer Bharati, and Jaishankar Prasad, to name a few. His story Maare Gaye Gulfaam was made into a movie Teesri Kasam, though Maila Aanchal seemed to have been ignored by our Hollywood copying Bollywood.
If I were to suggest a series of books to any Indian about his country, I would, apart from epics of Ramayana and Mahabharata, go on and hand this list: Anand Math by Bankim, Gora and Ghaira Bhare by Tagore, Godan by Prem Chand, Midnight's Children by Rushdie, Maila Anchal by Renu and Gunaahon ka Devta by Dharamveer Bharati (The titles missing from this list (except for English fiction and Sarat Chandra) are a measure of my own ignorance, and hence I'll be delighted to get any recommendations).
Language flourishes when people speaking it celebrate its richness, honor its bards, recognize the need for its evolution and admire scholarship. Hindi as a language needs more authors like Renu. But more important than that is the reader who can savor the delights offered by our language. Maila Aanchal, apart from its numerous merits in being descriptive and its range and depth of narrative, is a celebration of spoken Hindi language, the khari boli. The language as we hear and live it is brought to the page by Renu. While he talks about social change, and issues closer at heart to reformists in undertones, he also springs at us a well written marvel of the language, freely indulging, romancing as if, with local words and variations, and at times, openly mocking the bookish Hindi, that is the bane of our classrooms, certain newspapers, and self-styled authors.
By the emphasis placed on the use of highly Sanskritized, defunct words, and due to importance of English as language of knowledge and erudition, Hindi literature and language have suffered enormously. Perhaps those among you who read the Russian authors or even the classical British novelists, perhaps you will notice how our approach to Hindi (or our Indian languages) is similar to Russians or Brits had for their mother-tongues in comparison to French. Perhaps likewise, an array of brilliant writers, a free dose of nationalism inspired by a new Napolean, is what we need for our language to flourish as it must.
While Renu waits for you to admire his contribution, I urge you to pick Maila Aanchal, and enter his world and characters from not so long ago, from our own land, our own country. Maybe, like always, you will learn something new about yourselves, about us. Read it and you will find Doctor babu, Kamla, Lakshmi, S, Mahant, Tehsildaar, Socialists, the dwarf, the Panditji and other characters will live etched in your memory reminding you of one and many you have known.
http://sharmavivek.sulekha.com/blog/post/2007/03/maila-aanchal-by-phanishwar-nath-renu.htm
Nothing has changed in Bihar or the Maila Aanchal.
Just see the TV News coverage clippings! Renu changed his tone in Parti Pareekatha hoping that the Big Dam would change everything and his people would taste the fruits of freedom and development.
Nothing has changed!
It is the same landscape!
It is the smae human sacpe!
In all those villages inhibited by the poor, underclass and untouchables, minorities, you wont get a single House to get shelter, not even a cemented platfarm!
Bihar floods: A man-made disaster
http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=140554
The devastating floods in Bihar, caused by a breach in the Kosi barrage, have left many dead and more than 30 lakhs displaced. But the extent of the floods could have been lessened had the administration been alert to the impending tragedy..
BIHAR HAS been battling with horrific floods for the past 15 days. ‘Sorrow of Bihar’, Kosi river has devastated 16 districts of the state. More than 30 lakhs people have been affected by the floods and around a hundred lives have been lost in the water. Due to extent of devastation, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh declared the floods in Bihar as ‘national calamity’. Singh also announced a Rs 1000-crore relief package for the state. Other states of the country are also offering relief packages to Bihar.
Government of Bihar is trying hard to provide necessary help to flood affected people. But still people in most affected areas are complaining of not getting adequate relief materials. Rescue and relief operations are going on in Bihar, but it would succeed only when the flood waters recede.
The reason behind the floods in Bihar was due to breach on Kosi river barrage on the Indo - Nepal border. But one can’t deny human hand behind the devastating floods in Bihar. The calamity is also the result of negligent attitude of the Central and state government. According to a senior official of National Disaster Management, the barrage completed its estimated lifespan of 30 years way back in 1986. Since then, 22 years have passed, but neither the state government nor the Centre showed any interest in constructing a new barrage or renovating the old one.
In 1956, the Kosi barrage came into being after a bilateral agreement between India and Nepal. But years before its estimated lifespan of 30 years, the river started changing its course eastward. The then Bihar government was aware of the fact, but it did not asked the Centre for diplomatic level talks with the neighbouring country. Negligence by Nepal towards maintenance of the Kosi barrage, which was breached two weeks back was one of the reasons behind the floods. But Nitish Kumar-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government also remained silent about the impending disaster.
Despite the flood-prone history of Bihar, the state government never showed much interest in dealing with the situation in advance. In fact, since the country’s Independence, the Centre never initiated diplomatic talks with Nepal. Of course, floods occur due to natural causes such as incessant rains, but by constructing a series of high dams on the Indo – Nepal border the extent of floods could have been reduced.
Fact is that the Centre or the state governments wake up only when floods or other natural calamities comes and destroy everything. At the time of elections, the government makes tall claims, and forgets them with the passage of time. Such negligence of the government and its officials is also visible in man-made structures like bridges, flyovers, buildings, etc.
Other Articles by Md Mudassir Alam
Maoists didn't kill Saraswati: VHP general secretary
Mamata Banerjee open to talks over Nano row
Mayawati makes it to Forbes’ powerful women list
History created: Team India clinches ODI series
India's secular character under threat
more >>
There are several railway and road bridges across the country, which are very old and have completed their life span. But the concerned authorities don’t care to dismantle the old bridge or replace it with a new one. Every now and then we come across news of falling bridges and buildings, but no one cares about the casualty.
The unfolding tragedy in Bihar is an important lesson for the state government and the Centre as well. Had the necessary steps been taken on time, the 16 districts could have been saved from such devastation. Floods in Bihar have shocked the whole nation and has raised questions against our so-called ‘developing nation’ image. It is time for the government to wake up, rather than play blame game with each other and make it a political issue.
Once upon a Sankranti
http://www.indiatogether.org/2005/jan/opi-kosipast.htm
Half a century of harvests ago, the plans to control the flooding of the Kosi river got underway. The lives of those who live within its embankments have never been the same again; successive governments have failed them, and the practices that brought them such misery have remained firmly in place, notes Dinesh Mishra.
19 January 2005 - Fifty years ago on Makar Sankranti - 14 January 1955 - the first foundation stone for controlling the floods in country was laid in the village of Bhutaha, in Bihar's Madhubani district. The then Chief Minister of Bihar, Dr Shri Krishna Sinha, set off the plan to control the flooding of India's most vibrant river, the Kosi. Many decades after that beginning, it is debatable whether the embankments on either banks served the desired purpose, or if the cost paid by the people to achieve such flood control was justified. But there is something else we can pay attention to now.
With the river embanked by the project, some 386 villages spread over four districts - Saharsa, Supaul, Madhubani and Darbhanga - were trapped within the two embankments, and the waters of the Kosi pass over these villages every year. When the construction of the embankments began, the people were alerted, but it was 1956 before they understood what was going on and could raise the demand for rehabilitation. By then, the construction of the embankments was completed till Nirmali, some 50 kilometers south of the Indo-Nepal border. The Government assured the entrapped people that there would be only a marginal rise of four inches in the flood level within the embankments. The people disputed this, pointing out that the land around the Kosi slopes toward the west, and any rise in the flood level would spell doom for the people trapped within the embankments.
The response to their concern was indifferent, even calculating. In a meeting of the Kosi Control Board at Patna, on the 2nd March 1956, the members of the Central Water Commission opposed any move to resettle the embankment victims on the plea that that would set a bad precedent, and that people would start demanding rehabilitation in all such projects.
The floods of the Kosi in 1956 proved the villagers right; life within the embankments was devastated, and there was no doubt that more of this lay ahead in the years to come as well. Waterlogging outside the embankments was also significant; many villages were victims of stagnant rainwater that could not enter the river because of the embankments. A movement to rehabilitate villages trapped within the Kosi embankments gained momentum in 1957, but by this time the embankments had been further extended - to Mahishi on the eastern side and to Bhanthi on the west, both in Saharsa district. A total of 304 villages were trapped. As the resistance grew the government - at a cost of Rs. 112 millions - prepared a rehabilitation package but later found that this cost was disproportionate to the cost of the project itself (Rs. 370 millions), and the plans were dropped.
Pressure from villagers continued, however. This resulted in the announcement of a proportionate package of rehabilitation worth Rs. 21.2 millions. Deep Narain Singh, then Minister of Irrigaion in the State, made an announcement (3rd December 1958) in the Vidhan Sabha that,
The Government would provide land to the victims in the flood protected area, close to the embankment,
Government would arrange land for the services like schools, roads etc,
Rehabilitation sites will be provided with tanks, wells, tube-wells for water supply by the Government,
House Building Grants would be made available to the victims, and
Government would ensure easy access to the fields of the farmers by providing adequate number of boats.
Many elderly persons in the area recall that they were also promised jobs for at least one person per family in the Kosi Project. However, I did not find documentary evidence to substantiate this claim.
continue reading article ...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We're counting on you!
The article you are reading costs money to produce, publish, and archive. India Together relies on your annual financial support to meet these costs. If you are a regular reader, and haven't made an annual contribution, now is the time to change that. Support us at one of the following levels:
- Rs.1000 (recommended)
- Rs.5000 (Friends of India Together)
- Rs.500 (basic)
Contribute now | Why your support matters
p.s.: Your support is voluntary. Nevertheless, we rely on it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By 1960, only 70 villages were resettled; even at that slow rate, nonetheless, only 9 years should have been needed to ensure rehabilitation for all the embankment victims. However, by 1972-73, only 32,540 families of the total of about 45,000 families were given the first grant for constructing houses; 10,580 families were given the second installment and none had got the third and final installment. Besides, these embankment victims were expected to go their old villages for farming since they were not alloted any land for cultivation in the so called flood protected countryside. The rehabilitation sites too became waterlogged, and the people returned to their old villages. The government interpreted this retreat of the villagers as their affection for their ancestral properties, and on this excuse the rehabilitation process was abandoned before completion.
It was not possible to physically rehabilitate the victims of the Kosi Project, for the simple reason that it is impossible to arrange for so much of land in this thickly populated area. This was probably why the CM thought of economic rehabilitation instead; he was of the view that not all the land within the Kosi embankments would be ruined, and that agriculture would continue to be practised there. Against this background, the government appointed a committee in 1962 to look into the problems of agriculture, health, industry, revenue collection, extension of securities and cooperation. The Development Commissioner of the State, the Land Reforms Commissioner and the Chief Administrator of the Kosi Project were members of the committee.
This committee achieved nothing. Then, in 1967, another committee was constituted under the chairmanship of the Kosi Area Development Commissioner whose job was to suggest programmes for the embankment victims in the sectors of agriculture, cooperation, industrial development and economic rehabilitation. This committee, too, did not function. In 1981, another committee under the chairmanship of Chandra Kishor Pathak, former chairman of Saharsa District Board, was constituted to look into the problems of economic rehabilitation of the embankment victims. This committee gave its report in 1982 and the Government accepted its recommendations in 1987. Based on the recommendations of the Pathak Committee, the state government constituted Kosi Pirit Vikas Pradhikar (Kosi Sufferers Development Authority) in the same year.
While recommending the constitution of this Authority, Bindeshwari Dubey, then Chief Minister of Bihar, asserted that there might not be any other place in the country where so many people are exposed to the fury of the floods of a river. These people had lost all hope of their betterment and his 'determined Government' was committed to their overall development so that happiness would dawn on them. But, the Authority of the 'Determined Government' remains a defunct body. It does not have a building or an office of its own. It has no vehicles and 'deputation employees' man its functions. It has no budget either. At best, it can request the other departments to do certain things for the embankment victims. It has some chairs and tables in the Vikas Bhawan at Saharsa where its employees are occassionally seen.
For fifteen years the two committees set up to look into the problems of those within the embankments did nothing, and twenty more years have passed since a third committee made its recommendations.
The Authority decided, way back in 1989, that those living within the embankmemnts would not have to pay the ferrying costs for coming to or going out from their villages as they have to cross many channels of the rivers. This would have ensured free movement to their villages but could not be enforced. The Authority recommended to the Relief and Rehabilitation Department of the state to provide free boats to the embankment victims, at least, during the monsoon season. It could not get that favour. Most of the primary schools within the embankments do not have roofs over their buildings. Who will go to study there and who would teach in such places? The doctors and the employees of the Health Department do not visit the Health Centres and they cannot visit there during the rainy season even if they want to because of heavy currents in the river. Who will get the treatment and who then will treat them?
It is written in the provisions of the Authority that fifteen per cent of Class-3 and 4 jobs in the districts that have benefited from the Kosi Project would be reserved for the embankment victims of the Kosi. Nobody has received jobs with that qualification so far, not even in the Kosi Sufferers Development Authority. There is no electricity, no pucca roads, no college, no hospitals, no cinema house, no bank, no block or any other office of the Government and there is no sign of any modern development within the Kosi embankments. No outsider wants to have marital relations with those in the embankments. Without the employment found by those migrating to places like Delhi, Haryana, Punjab or Gujarat, even simple existence would be hard. Struggling for the rights of these people is also not anymore on the agenda of NGOs and political parties - no one has time for a forgotten issue.
It is rumoured that some offices have been opened in Nepal to investigate the proposed Barahkshetra Dam on the Kosi that is expected to solve all the flood problems of Bihar, and that the Central Government has given a grant of Rs. 290 millions to realize this dream. One wonders whether there is any space for those trapped within the embankments of the Kosi in the project. To them, it matters very little where the office is; they are merely silenced witnesses to a ravaged past. Their silence is simply made more eerie by the fact that the 'development' that destroyed their lives still flows along the same course, elsewhere up the river. The bitter harvest is unending. ⊕
Dinesh Mishra
19 Jan 2005
India is ill equipped to face disasters: Assocham
Bs Reporter / New Delhi September 3, 2008, 18:10 IST
http://www.business-standard.com/india/storypage.php?tp=on&autono=45919
The country’s leading corporates have unleashed their pent up feelings, severely complaining that India is ill equipped to face disasters as it is yet to put in place an effective Disaster Management Plan
a survey conducted by industry body Assocham, nearly 78 per cent of the country’s 400 corporates have admitted this.
312 CEO’s mostly belonging to companies in telecom, power generation and transmission, oil, gas, sugar, infrastructure, hospitals, railways, textiles, agro products have strongly felt the need for creating a sound and proactive disaster management team to respond to contingencies arising out of natural calamities.
Nearly 65 per cent of the respondents felt that Tusnami which struck coastal part of India about 4 years ago had galvanised the Indian administration to come out on war footings with disaster management plans.
However, around 300 CEOs still hold that after Tusnami settled, the disaster management was not given the required attention.
Over 55 per cent corporates participating in the survey said that the involvement of private sector, common man, institutions like schools, colleges and even NGOs in handling disasters is extremely negligible.
Even, media does not play a required role to suggest measures to handle natural calamities, barring reporting them in a sensitive manner, they added.
The Chamber has also emphasised that Disaster Management should be made a permanent chapter in curricula of all schools so that students are imparted necessary physical training to handle disaster like situation before the forces are called upon to take on such exigencies and calamities.
Over 70 per cent of the respondents, however, expressed satisfaction that in order to respond effectively to floods and earthquake risk mitigation, Ministry of Home Affairs has initiated National Disaster Risk Management Programme in all States but much more needs to be done.
According to them, a comprehensive programme should be taken up to forewarn the people about possibilities of floods and earthquake so that they evacuate themselves to safer places and sites in advance as precautionary measures.
The Chamber is of the view that just a territorial army has been created in the oil sector particularly in its downstream branch to meet any sort of exigencies happening in refining and exploration front, a similar force is recommended to be made to handle disasters.
A special corpus needs to be created for this purpose in which the private sector should be asked to make 50 per cent contribution and also send their experts in schools and institutions that are mandated to create the suggested force.
There is a need of greater emphasis on infrastructure in large cities and the government has to set aside a dedicated fund.
Over the last 15 years, there has been a 30-35 per cent increase in urban population and most cities suffer from water shortage.
Bihar devastated by Kosi
26 Aug 2008, 0520 hrs IST, Subodh Varma,TNN
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Bihar_devastated_by_Kosi/articleshow/3405589.cms
NEW DELHI: Every once in a while, nature reminds humans that it is the boss. The Kosi river, which gathers water from some of the highest mountains in the world, including Everest, and enters India in north Bihar, has changed its course and shifted over 120km eastwards, going back to a course it had abandoned more than 300 years ago.
In the process it has rendered useless more than 300km of embankments that had been built to control its ever-angry waters. The effect has been enormous, inundating numerous towns and villages that had not seen such floods for decades.
It is a Katrina moment in Bihar — nobody expected Hurricane Katrina to breach the levees protecting New Orleans, that too in 53 places, flooding 80% of the city and leaving a trail of never-seen-before death and destruction.
Just like the people of New Orleans, who felt secure because the levees were there, the people of Madhepura, Araria and Supaul districts had faith in the embankments built on both sides of the Kosi to keep the waters from flooding the adjacent plains. But they had not reckoned with the enormous pent-up force unleashed by 51 billion cubic metres of water. Finally, it broke through the embankment just after the barrage at Bhimnagar — and swept into its old course.
The Kosi is called the Sorrow of Bihar because among all the fast-flowing rivers that collect water in Nepal and speed down the mountains into the plains of Bihar, it is the most dangerous. It carries over 81 million tons of silt every year in its roiling waters.
And, it is a young river, not yet having matured enough to settle on a course. As it enters the northern plains the incline drops off, and the water starts slowing down. Over the years silt gets deposited giving Kosi its braided shape — it has several channels that diverge and then again merge, like a braid, as the water tries to find new ways to go further. As it shifts it leads a deposit of sand, which renders the land barren.
Seen from a satellite, the area looks like a conical fan. Created by hundreds of years of shifting, it is the largest such cone in the world, covering an area of over 15,000 square km. The tip is near Chatra on the Nepal border. The cone is made up of various courses of Kosi and the land in between, which gets submerged during floods.
The Kosi used to wind its way on the eastern-most course. But as the silting raised the level of the bed, it kept shifting westwards. However, because there is an incline from the west to the east, the waters couldn’t move westward any more and returned to the eastern course once again.
Experts argue that building embankments allowed too much silt deposition in a shorter stretch, leading to devastation. In other words, young Kosi is not being allowed to grow up and settle down. Meanwhile, people have to adjust to a new reality, the Kosi flowing in its new course, redefining fields, roads and boundaries.
Major Historical Disasters (Natural & Manmade) With 20th Century Timelines Available at Infoplease
Learn History of Worldwide Disasters, Tips for Survival From Trusted Reference Site
http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/major-historical-disasters-natural-/story.aspx?guid=%7BE1522964-DADD-4DF7-9606-DFC396A38978%7D&dist=hppr
Last update: 6:00 a.m. EDT Aug. 27, 2008
BOSTON, Aug 27, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- On Aug. 29, New Orleans will mark the third anniversary of Hurricane Katrina with a candlelight vigil in Jackson Square -- a powerful reminder of the impact that both natural and unnatural disasters have on the world. The trusted reference site Infoplease offers insight into major disasters with in-depth details and information on the impact of these cataclysmic events.
The site features a 2008 disasters timeline that includes details, such as casualties and cost of damages, on every major disaster so far this year. Other historical disasters on the site are organized by type of event and intensity, ranging from earthquakes and floods to terrorist attacks and calamities at sporting events.
"Nearly all of us have -- or will -- face some sort of disaster in our lives -- whether it is of the magnitude of an earthquake or tornado or a flooded basement from a rain storm," said Jess M. Brallier, publisher, Infoplease. "Infoplease's in-depth information and timelines on world disasters put these events into perspective and remind us that the world has recovered from even the most destructive catastrophes."
Compare Katrina to other historical disasters with Infoplease's exploration of the devastating natural disaster and the faltering relief response from all levels of government. Visit the site to learn how a million people were displaced, 1,800 died and New Orleans and other cities are still struggling to recover from Katrina and its catastrophic aftermath.
Yet, nearly a century before Hurricane Katrina, the United States faced its most devastating natural disaster -- the San Francisco earthquake in April 1906. Visitors to Infoplease can follow the events of the day the earth moved in the Bay Area and the following four days of fires that took a huge toll in human life and destroyed more than 500 blocks of the city. A census facts timeline compares the city of San Francisco in 1906 to the vital, rebuilt city of today.
The 21st century has seen more than its fair share of disasters. Timelines on Infoplease depict month by month the actions of Mother Nature and humans that have ravaged cities, states and countries. In 2008 alone, the world has dealt with Cyclone Nargis in Myanmar that killed more than 75,000 people; a major earthquake in China that took 67,000 lives; rampant wildfires in California and the northwest; raging Iowa floods; and an unprecedented number of severe tornadoes in the United States.
The United States has also seen its most catastrophic manmade disaster ever this century -- the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. As the seventh anniversary of that fateful day approaches, visitors to Infoplease will find a timeline that unfolds the events of Sept. 11 in Boston, New York City, Washington, D.C., and Shanksville, Pa., as well as the days that followed.
As history shows, you never know when a disaster -- large or small -- is going to strike. To help deal with these unexpected events, Infoplease offers a disaster survival guide that features tips for surviving a number of different adverse situations. The reference Web site also provides an in-depth article on the chances of facing a lightning strike and what to do if you are caught in a thunderstorm.
About Information Please
Information Please ( http://www.Infoplease.com) is an authoritative, current and comprehensive reference Web site that covers world news, includes thousands of in-depth articles, interactive tools and offers an atlas, almanac, encyclopedia, dictionary and thesaurus. With content written and maintained by professional editors, Infoplease.com is committed to providing users with the most authoritative, accurate and timely reference content.
Information Please is part of Pearson, the world's largest integrated education company. Pearson's other primary operations include the Financial Times Group and the Penguin Group.
SOURCE Information Please
http://www.Infoplease.com
Copyright (C) 2008 PR Newswire. All rights reserved
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
Search All Our Sites at SpaceBank
EARTH OBSERVATION
India To Launch Exclusive Satellite To Track Natural Disasters
Bangalore, India (SPX) Nov 01, 2005
In the wake of the recent earthquake which caused havoc in India and Pakistan, killing thousands of people, the Government of India has decided to launch an exclusive satellite that can track natural disasters, a top official said.
G Madhavan Nair, chief of Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO), stated in Bangalore that India would launch the Radar Imaging Satellite (RISAT), configured for disaster management, with in a couple of years.
"Most of the disasters that happen relate to climate or the weather, like cyclones or the floods have, and we have to look through the clouds. The radar imaging satellites has become important. We are working on that and we hope such satellites will be operational within a couple of years," Nair told a function to celebrate the 32nd foundation day of the Bangalore chapter of premier business school, Indian Institute of Management.
India, which has launched 10 remote sensing satellites since 1988 in addition to several broadcast satellites, launched this year a satellite that can map every house and street in the sub-continent.
CARTOSAT-1 would help urban and rural planning, land and water management, relief operations and environmental assessments.
Experts say some 56 million Indians are hit by disaster each year but there is no long-term policy to prepare for and manage these natural and man-made calamities.
A recent report on the calamities said that on average, disasters in India kill 5,063 people, affect more than 56 million people and cost some 1.88 billion dollars every year.
It said floods hit 11.2 per cent of the land and 28 percent is hit by drought.
More than half the land is vulnerable to earthquakes and the 7,516-km (4,700-mile) coastline is whipped by cyclones that pummel the eastern coast, specially in Orissa and Andhra Pradesh.
Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article
Related Links
SpaceDaily
Search SpaceDaily
Subscribe To SpaceDaily Express
Earth Observation News - Suppiliers, Technology and Application
http://www.spacemart.com/reports/India_To_Launch_Exclusive_Satellite_To_Track_Natural_Disasters.html
Man made calamities
Source: Leader writer: RK Lakhi Kant
Posted: 2005-11-12
http://www.kanglaonline.com/index.php?template=headline&newsid=1121&typeid=0&
There are some natural phenomena like floods, cyclones, tsunamis, earthquakes etc. that cannot be predicted. But still science has advanced so much that large scale death and destruction can be avoided in many cases like the hurricanes which hit the some areas in the USA recently. Almost whole cities were evacuated before the storms hit the areas. Still other calamities like floods and earthquakes are to be faced as there is not much anyone can do about it. The devastating earthquake in Pakistan and India only recently is an example of how unpredictable and out of control of humans such events are. These events are concerning nature and beyond humans to fight. But there are other events that cause similar misfortune among the people and which have completely man made causes which at times are due to the foolishness or lack of farsightedness of some people. Some examples of such events are riots, carnages, ethnic cleansing, large scale wars etc. All these are preventable if only the main actors in such events were more humane and had a larger sense of responsibility or a sense of brotherhood with others. There are many minor events also which do not cause so many deaths or large scale loss but which are equally disastrous when seen in the long run. Take for instance the state of communication in the state. It has been in a state of total disarray and mismanagement through the years since Manipur became a state and in fact even before that. But the level of awareness of our politicians and legislators regarding this problem is so wayward and low that this problem has remained unsolved for a long time and in future too there seems to be little hope for the state. Those who are to do their bit to improve conditions keep blaming the Centre for our problems. But it is not the Centre which has to look into every little problem of ours. It is only ourselves who dwell in this place who must take the initiative and solve our problems sincerely. The level of awareness of our leaders seems to go only as far as passing the buck to others. This brand of wisdom has failed us time and again. There is hardly a leader in the state who can see beyond petty political games and be a true leader.
The problem is not in just one area but like a disease it is spread out over many areas. The government today is severely crippled due to lack of leadership and insight into problems facing the people. There seems to be no need for any physical or moral qualifications for being a leader in this state. The current political situation in the state where there is a demand from the ruling legislators for a reshuffle in the ministry is another example of how things are going on in the state. For the people it hardly matters whether the reshuffle takes place or not as their condition would remain the same in any case. The politicians seem to be interested only in such matters of selfish interest and are hardly concerned for improving the administration. The various bandhs, blockades, dharnas etc. taken up by the public very frequently nowadays is not to be blamed only on them. In truth it is due to the political leaders that such eventualities are taking place. And the fact is that due to continued exposure to such means the public is beginning to be led to believe that the use of solely such means can actually bring about change in their condition without any other effort from their side. This way the quality of their citizenship is falling drastically. This matter should be of urgent concern to us. While natural calamities do not come so frequently and are anyway beyond our control it is the man made calamities we must be beware of.
Times of India reports from New Delhi:
Though called in late by the civil administration for rescue and relief work in flood-hit Bihar, the armed forces are now hopeful of being able to evacuate the estimated 3 lakh people still marooned in the affected areas in the next two-three days with the help of other agencies.
After shifting into “top gear” only late last week after the “requisite clearances” came through, the armed forces are stepping up their deployment in districts like Madhepura, Supaul, Araria, Purnia and Katihar.
Read More:
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Army_hopes_to_evacuate_3_lakh_people_in_3_days/articleshow/3438319.cms
Gogoi directed the Jorhat district authorities to ensure adequate relief to the people with food scarcity looming large in the island as supply of essentials was hit by the rising water level.
The waist-deep flood waters engulfed 167 villages with a population of 1.5 lakh and was threatening fresh areas in the island, which houses several 'satras' (Vaishnavite monasteries).
The authorities were forced to shift 34 prisoners from Goramur sub-divisional jail to Jorhat central jail following the inundation in Majuli, the sources said.
The situation in lower Assam's Rangiya sub-division too is critical following breaches in four embankments by Puthimari river.
With NH-31, the lifeline of the north east, still under flood water, road communication with the rest of the country is snapped for the fourth day on Wednesday, the sources said.
The army continued to assist the government in providing relief to the affected people across the state, the sources said.
The situation in the Kaziranga National Park, famed for its one-horned rhinos, is also critical with more than 50 percent of the park area under flood waters.
The animals, including rhinos and elephants, are taking shelter on high platforms constructed within the park.
The park authorities have set up barricades along the highway for limiting vehicle speed to 40 kmph for protecting animals from being run over while migrating to the hills of neighbouring Karbi Anglong, the sources said.
Brahmaputra was flowing above the danger level in Dibrugarh, Sonitpur, Dhubri, Jorhat, Kamrup districts. In Guwahati, the river has touched the danger level. (ANI)
Nevertheless, high-level team of the officials from the Centre lead by Cabinet Secretary K M Chandrasekhar met the Chief Minister Nitish Kumar and senior state officials in Patna on Tuesday. The Cabinet Secretary informed the Chief Minister about the ongoing relief operations carried out by the armed forces and other central agencies and assured him that the efforts would continue in full swing. He has asked the state administration to provide the details of further assistance required by them. Kumar appreciated the assistance given by the Armed Forces and desired that the main focus should be on rehabilitation and reconstruction efforts. He sought for more columns of Army for evacuation of the marooned persons and the Air Force for dropping of relief material.
The State Relief Commissioner has requested for more supplies of food, medicines and baby food. He has also sought veterinary services and establishment of relief camps wherever the railway heads are available. He also emphasized that efforts should be strengthened for evacuation of the stranded people. The Indian Air Force is operating 11 helicopters, 3 IL-76, 13 AN-32 and 2 Avro aircraft for evacuation and dropping of relief materials.
About 100 boats are being sent to the flood affected areas today.
Defence Secretary Vijay Singh, Secretary of Ministry of Water Resources U N Panjiar, Secretary Border Management Jarnail Singh and other senior officials accompanied the Cabinet Secretary.
Senior BJP leader LK Advani met Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh on Wednesday to seek a solution to the problem of recurrent floods in Bihar, where around 25 lakh people have been rendered homeless in the worst ever floods in the Kosi region.
Advani urged Dr. Singh to find both long and short term solutions to the problem of recurrent floods in Bihar.
Advani, who made an aerial survey of flood-ravaged regions of Bihar along with State Chief Minister Nitish Kumar on Tuesday, said, "Since the recurrent floods in Bihar caused by rivers originating in Nepal have international dimensions, I would meet the Prime Minister on Wednesday to seek both long and short term solutions to the problem in coordination with the government in the Himalayan country,"
"In today's situation, everybody should come together to help rather than indulging in mud sledging," Advani added.
The state's main opposition Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) had earlier lashed out at the state administration, accusing it of laxity in providing relief to the flood victims.
The flooding, the worst in 50 years, was caused after the Kosi River breached a dam in Nepal. This unleashed huge waves of water that smashed mud embankments downstream in Bihar state.
The waters of Kosi gushed into the state inundating vast areas and affecting around two million people.
SC declines hearing on PIL for repair of Kosi river embankment
9/2/2008
The Supreme Court declined to hear a PIL seeking directions to the Union government to take up the matter regarding the repairing and strengthening of the embankment of Kosi river, located in the territory of Nepal.
A bench comprising Chief Justice K G Balakrisnan and Justices P Sathasivam and J M Panchal asked the counsel for the petitioners "Can this court do anything in the matter? The government is already taking all necessary steps for the relief and resce of those marooned in the floods in Bihar." Praveen Chandra and Sanjay Kumar Vidyarthi in their petition have also prayed to the apex court to issue a writ of mandamus to the government to take appropriate measures to ensure that the problem does not occur in future.
The petitioners have also expressed dissatisfaction with the efforts of the state as well as the Union government in helping out millions of people marooned and uprooted to the worst flood situation that has occurred, submerging 13 districts of Bihar.
The state was hit by floods on August 18 when the Kosi embankment situated in Nepal was breached.
The apex court will, however, hear the petition on September 15 along with another petition already pending in the court.
Around 26.68 lakh people are entrapped in the flood and over 20 lakh people are still waiting to be evacuated to safer places. The Army has already taken over the relief and rescue work in the state.
UNI
PTI reports from Saharsa/Purnia (Bihar): The Kosi may have changed its course killing and displacing many in Bihar, but the river has also "sank" religious differences as evident in relief camps where RSS men were seen serving food to Muslims.
Clad in khaki shorts and caps, RSS men are serving gram and flattened rice to Muslim flood victims in a relief camp at Saharsa.
The camp being run by 'Seva Bharti', a Sangh Parivar outfit, at the zila school campus at Saharsa presents a rare but heartening sight where the devastating deluge of Kosi has sunk bitterness and differences.
"Over a 100 people of my community are taking shelter here for more than a week now and we have absolutely no complaint .... Life cannot be better than this in a relief shelter," says Mohammed Salauddin, who fled Parba village in Madhepura district along with his family to escape the flood fury.
In another camp, a kilometre away, a joyful reunion was taking place. The prayers of Phulo Devi, who has observed fasts on all occasions of 'Teej', have been answered.
Nago Paswan, her husband, who works as a farmhand in far away Punjab and had not visited their village in Murliganj in Madhepura for the last couple of years, rushed home when he learned of the flood havoc, but was stranded at Saharsa.
As luck would have it, he met Phulo and his children Rinku, Mamta and Rahul at the relief camp.
"I am relieved that my family is alive .... I had given up hope after watching on TV the destruction caused in Murliganj," says Nago.
Inept response to floods outrages India
Wed Sep 3, 2008 3:26am EDT Email | Print | Share| Reprints | Single Page | Recommend (-) [-] Text [+]
1 of 1Full SizeFeatured Broker sponsored link
By Bappa Majumdar
PURNEA, India, Sept 3 (Reuters) - For several days, Urmi Mahato and her family were glued to the radio and TV, eager for information on rising floodwaters and waiting for the government to tell them whether and when to evacuate their home.
The warning never came, and officials assured there was no danger. Then one morning a wall of water crumpled the river's mud embankment, swamping the village and sweeping away her family.
"I do not know where to look for them, there is no one to help me," said the 24-year-old woman, sitting at a government relief camp in Bihar, one of India's poorest states.
The floods have forced more than three million people from their homes, destroyed 100,000 ha (250,000 acres) of farmland and killed at least 90 people.
Media reports say the toll is at least 10 times higher, after the Kosi river, which originates in Nepal, burst a dam last month and unleashed the worst flooding in Bihar in 50 years.
But the tragedy is not entirely nature's doing. Experts and aid agencies blame government ineptness for not only failing to warn people but also for mishandling relief.
In the most shocking example, SOS fax messages sent by engineers at the Kosi dam warning of impending disaster were ignored in Bihar's capital Patna, the Mail Today newspaper said.
The faxes piled up on the relevant bureaucrat's desk because he was on leave and no deputy had been appointed. No one reacted even when warnings were sent to other officials, the paper said, calling for prosecutions for criminal negligence.
"We have come across such reports, and we will definitely look into this issue once all this is over," Nitish Mishra, the state's disaster management minister, told Reuters in Bihar.
"There should definitely be some accountability."
Anger is mounting and stick-wielding victims have resorted to looting food warehouses and trucks in some areas.
The threat of disease is also rising, but the government says it could take months before people can return home from camps.
The monsoon comes every year and also caused severe flooding in Bihar last year, but authorities admit they were not prepared for the scale of the disaster.
"Neither us nor the people thought such a devastation could happen so suddenly," said Mishra.
FAILURE TO THINK AHEAD
But aid agencies are unimpressed by the speed of the relief effort. Hundreds of thousands of people are still trapped on rooftops, elevated roads or surrounded by water in distant villages, without any food or water.
"On the ground, preparedness is missing in the current response," said ActionAid's P.V. Unnikrishnan. "Preparedness cannot be a knee-jerk reaction and currently preparing against disasters is not on the radar of the government."
After days of delay, India finally stepped up evacuation and relief this week by deploying 14 more columns of army personnel, while three naval companies were also asked to help.
More than 560,000 people have been evacuated, and 200,000 have been moved to government relief camps, officials said.
Environmentalists say the government should have de-silted the river as Kosi, known as the "river of sorrow" for its ability to quickly change course, leaves behind heavy silt and debris.
"The floods have pushed Bihar back to 50 years and authorities should be blamed for a slow response not the river," said Rameshwar Prasad, a local historian and environmentalist.
The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) said the floods, as well hurricanes in the Atlantic, were reminders of the risks of ever more extreme weather linked to a changing climate.
Indian experts agree, saying the government must wake up to the complex issue of climate change quickly.
"It looks unusual for such heavy rains to hit Nepal and Bihar at the same time and cause floods so regularly," Sunita Narain, a climate change expert said in New Delhi.
"We don't have time now, we better get our act together now and prepare to face disasters tomorrow." (Editing by Simon Denyer)
Curse of Kosi: A legend comes true
31 Aug 2008, 0203 hrs IST, Abhay Mohan Jha,TNN
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Curse_of_Kosi_A_legend_comes_true/articleshow/3426653.cms
MADHEPURA: For both the new generation in Madhepura and the adjoining districts of Supaul, Araria and Purnia, until now the Kosi was just a river held at bay by the embankment near the Nepal border. Its fury was merely a tale carried over generations by word of mouth, folklores and songs. School textbooks too described it as Bihar's Sorrow. Just as the Huang Ho or the Yellow river was China's Sorrow. But it was all just a tale. The Kosi had been tamed by the embankment. Also, it had spared this region in its eastern basin by changing course to more than 100km to the west over the past 100 years.
The long hiatus nourished a tradition of farming, dairying, trade and culture. But the Kosi's tale has come back from the dead. The reincarnation of its anger is bringing death and devastation in a rapidly spreading arc. The toothless tales of its past fury are suddenly alive and residents now feel the sting they missed in dadi ma's tales. "Even village elders do not remember anything remotely similar to the tragedy that has unfolded here," Khushilal Rishidev, a landless dalit labourer from Singheshwar said.
Kamleshwari Prasad, 84, a farmer from Mathai in Madhepura, does remember scenes somewhat similar to today's, though. "The main road of Madhepura town fell in the Kosi's course in the 1942 floods," he remembered the plying of boats in the town then. But there are no boats at hand today when the river is determined to drown the entire township and beyond.
"The thana (police station) and the block office were shifted to 6km away to Mathai then," Prasad recalled, just as he solemnly saw people shifting out on Saturday.
Murliganj, a market town talked about as the economic hub of the Madhepura hinterland has been wiped out. With the town on the verge of drowning, any hope of rescuing the thousands marooned in the vicinity of Murliganj too seems to have sunk. "My father, a diabetic, and my children are dying of starvation in the village," cried Bam Shankar Chowdhary of Jorgama. "Ab koi nahin bachega," Aditya Singh of Korlahi village said in resignation.
Octagenarian Basant Kumar Sinha has fled his Madhepura home for the first time. "Kosi has been unkind in the winter of his life," nephew Rahul rued.
"Kamla bigdal, Kosi bigdal, bigaid gail Bhutahi-Balan. Baal bachcha sab duibb maral, ruis gela bhagwan (The Kamla has got furious, so have the Kosi and the Bhutahi-Balan. Our children and families have been drowned. The gods have turned their heads away)," goes a Maithili folk song. Its angst is searingly in motion with the roiling waters of the Kosi. Bihar's sorrow has come in a devastating reincarnation.
Missing the river for the dam
3 Sep, 2008, 0003 hrs IST,Sudhirendar Sharma,
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Guest_Writer/Missing_the_river_for_the_dam/articleshow/3438078.cms
The simplistic notion that a high dam in upper reaches can bring down the impact of floods in Kosi seems reflective of failed Indian hydrocracy, an expression gaining currency in regional water discourses. Raising contentious high dam issue at this stage, when the political atmosphere in Nepal is charged in favour of annulling all previous treaties including the 1954 Kosi treaty, will amount to diplomatic arrogance.
Nepal has long argued that a high dam doesn’t favour her, and that the projected benefits have been grossly exaggerated. These claims have been further accentuated by the raw deal reportedly received in the previous water-sharing arrangements, including the 1959 Gandak treaty. The present deluge upstream of the Bhimnagar barrage on Kosi has only amplified the accumulated aspersions.
The dilapidated state of the barrage could not convince this writer and other members of an independent fact-finding mission in early March that it could carry its designed discharge of 950,000 cusecs. The silt choked east and the west bank canals emanating from the barrage, their combined irrigation capacities reduced by two-third on account of defunct silt ejectors, could only add pressure on the main structure and the embankments upstream.
Sharing preliminary findings with the press, the fact finding mission had warned: “...not only are floods in Bihar manmade but that the worse has yet to come, should the political economy of flood control continue to promote ‘embankment’ as the only solution to the scourge of floods.” That the worse would come so soon couldn’t be predicted, but it undoubtedly had the making of a catastrophe.
Delhi has got its flood action plan consistently wrong over the years, and so has Patna. Yet, both never stop either blaming the rains or Kathmandu for it. Like floods, it is an annual ritual for politicians in Bihar to reiterate that Nepal has released water and that a high dam is the only solution to control floods. Little do unsuspecting masses realise that if there is no dam, how could water be stored upstream? But the myth persists!
Shockingly, however, flood control measures over the years have turned north Bihar into a watery grave for thousands. Jacketing the silt-laden rivers has helped flood prone area increase three fold in the state since Independence, from a low of 25 lakh to a high of 68 lakh hectare today. It amounts to no less than 73% of the entire land mass that remains prone under normal floods.
It is tragic that a catastrophic flood only sends alarming signals, emergency aerial surveys and fresh relief packages being the temporary outcomes. That over two million people are permanently trapped between the flood control embankments and an estimated eight million are faced with acute water-logging outside of the embankments are hard facts that continue to get ignored, year after year.
What instead gets attention is jacketing of the rivers, over 3,465 km long embankments have been built in Bihar since 1952. More are in the offing; a Rs 792-crore package to tame the Bagmati has been approved and another proposal to embank the tributaries of Mahananda at an estimated cost of Rs 850 crore has been planned. The business of embankment building reflects politician-bureaucrat-contractor nexus at its best.
India rescue at 'crucial' stage
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7595223.stm
Officials say that water levels are coming down
Efforts to rescue flood victims have entered a "final and crucial" stage in the northern Indian state of Bihar, the senior official in charge has said.
Prataya Amrit told the BBC News website that 60,000 to 80,000 people needed to be rescued from "six critical areas" in the districts of Sepaul and Madhepura.
He said more than 650,000 people had been rescued from the affected areas. More than 90 people have died.
Water levels in the flooded areas have come down "drastically", he said.
Meanwhile, monsoon waters have been causing havoc in India's Assam state, as well as in Nepal and Bangladesh.
Disease fears
The authorities in Bihar have been criticised for failing to rescue flood victims well over a week after the scale of the flooding became apparent.
Monsoon rains caused the river Kosi to change course, severely affecting areas not normally prone to floods.
Mr Amrit said that more than 3,000 soldiers, aided by the navy, had rescued most of the stranded people.
"We are looking to complete rescue and evacuation operations over the next two days," he said.
More than 250 relief camps have been set up
"It is the most crucial part of the operation because these are areas which have borne the maximum brunt of the floods."
These areas are in the worst affected districts of Sepaul and Madhepura.
However, a non-governmental organisation (NGO) in Bihar, Mandan Bharti Jagriti Samaj (MBJS), says that 500,000 people still needed to be rescued.
Mr Amrit said that more than 275,000 flood victims had been lodged in more than 250 relief camps in Sepaul, Madhepura, Saharsa and Araria districts.
Tens of thousands of survivors have crowded into unsanitary relief camps, where tensions are growing over the desperate lack of emergency supplies.
There have been reports of flood victims looting relief near some of the camps.
Mr Amrit admitted that there was a problem. "There is a gap between the demand and supply of relief material. We are trying to bridge this gap," he said.
With the numbers of people in the camps expected to nearly double in the coming days, there are fears that poor conditions could lead to outbreaks of diseases such as cholera.
The UN warned that "the heat, combined with limited supplies of safe drinking water and poor hygiene conditions, poses a great risk of water and vector-borne diseases".
Nepal affected
The disaster began on 18 August when the Kosi broke its eastern bank in Nepal, where the river is often called the Saptakoshi.
The river's flow is regulated by a barrage - on the Nepalese side of the border - which was built in the late 1950s.
Under a joint agreement India, agreed to pay for the work and be responsible for its maintenance.
Some analysts point out that the structure was built only as a short-term solution, meant to last 20 or 30 years.
Others accuse the Indian government of having failed in its duty to maintain and repair the defences. If they had, they argue, the river could have been kept on course.
Indian engineers say the Nepalese authorities did not give them the safe access they needed to carry out the work and that there were labour problems.
Massive natural silting is also a major problem. Critics say joint efforts to control that silting were also inadequate this year.
In Nepal itself, officials say hundreds of people have been hit by illnesses such as diarrhoea and pneumonia, and an estimated 50,000 are homeless.
They say nearly 1,000 houses have been completely destroyed, and that power supplies and transport have been severely affected.
The costs to the economy are now estimated at one billion Nepalese rupees ($14.25m).
Bihar govt's negligent attitude responsible for floods: Minister
Press Trust Of India / New Delhi September 03, 2008, 18:44 IST
Senior RJD leader and Union Minister of State for Water Resources Jaiprakash Narayan Yadav today accused the Bihar government of massive flood in the state by being "totally negligent" in taking preventive measures.
Yadav alleged that Bihar State Water Resources Department, till August 17, kept on giving reports from the flood control cell that all the embankments under its jurisdiction were safe.
However, when a breach in the east Kosi embankment at Kusaha in Nepal occurred on August 18, Yadav said, the Bihar Government came up with a report that erosions were taking place at the Kosi dam in Upper Nepal on Bahothan embankment for the past several days.
According to Yadav, the report also said regional engineers had been continuously working to make it safe but some anti-social elements forced out the labourers working to protect the embankment and consequently pressure increased at the embankment.
Yadav said the government further stated in its August 18 report that the flood control team could not reach to control the situation at the spot following a law and order problem created by Nepalese and the local administration's failure in containing it.
"This is how the government played with its own report to steer clear of its responsibility. This is not a heresay disclosure but facts based on documents," Yadav said showing the copies of the Bihar Government reports to the reporters.
He said it has been notified that how and when work has to be started and completed in Kosi area.
Bihar's worst floods, yet most babus sit idle
3 Sep 2008, 0124 hrs IST, Pranava K Chaudhary ,TNN
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Bihars_worst_floods_but_most_babus_sit_idle/articleshow/3437102.cms
PATNA: There is no shortage of bureaucrats in Bihar. Yet, only a chosen few are engaged in the biggest-ever relief operations in flood-hit areas of the state. The rest have been mysteriously kept away from the crisis areas. In the absence of any defined assignment, most are keeping themselves abreast of the situation through news bulletins.
The bureaucrats, though, are willing to involve themselves in the massive humanitarian mission underway. But the government doesn’t seem to be paying heed.
‘‘I want to be involved in relief operations. I want to share my experience at this time of crisis,’’ said a senior IPS officer. A number of senior IAS officers with years of experience are virtually sitting idle in the secretariat. There is little work with hardly any official assignments. ‘‘I am drawing a hefty salary for doing nothing. The government doesn’t consider me fit for such exigency,’’ complained a secretary rank bureaucrat.
At least a dozen secretaries have admitted that a ‘‘culture of silence’’ prevails in the corridors of power. ‘‘Those who have dared to utter a word which is not suited to the ‘Raja’ have been relegated to the background,’’ said a disgruntled senior IPS officer. The list of those who have dared to speak out and have paid a heavy price is long.
Till date, the government does not have a full-fledged disaster management secretary. The over-burdened principal secretary road construction department R K Singh has had additional charge of disaster management department during the past six months.
Bihar State Bridge Corporation MD, Pratayay Amrit, has recently been assigned as additional commissioner of disaster management department. Bihar CM Nitish Kumar has the disaster management department portfolio.
Senior IAS officers posted in ‘‘innocuous’’ departments allege that they have been deliberately kept away from prestigious departments. Bihar’s devastating floods, they point out, require the services of the state’s large contingent of experienced bureaucrats at ground zero to monitor the mammoth rescue operation.
Instead of sending experienced officials, the government chose to deploy state cadres officials (some of them are on the verge of retirement) to monitor the relief operations.
The whole exercise of appointing special DMs in flood hit districts has turned futile. During last year’s flood, the government had also appointed special DMs which hardly made any difference, an official pointed out. ‘‘Special DMs and disaster management department are engaged in compiling laundry list statistics rather than rushing relief materials,’’ said an official.
Newborns in Bihar named after Kosi
3 Sep 2008, 0302 hrs IST, Abhay Mohan Jha,TNN
SAHARSA: The Kosi has brought doom to Bihar. But amid the deluge and destruction, the turbulent river has also brought smiles to some families. As some pregnant women delivered in shelter camps this week, the newborns were named after the river which has snatched away everything from hundreds of thousands of families in the state.
On Tuesday evening, as volunteers at a camp here gathered to prepare Wednesday’s menu for the flood victims, they also planned a celebration for Pinki, 20, and her husband Sudhir Sah, a couple displaced by the Kosi from their village in Madhepura. Pinki gave birth to a girl on Monday. ‘‘A daughter’s birth is auspicious,’’ Amit Swarnkar, a volunteer, said, ‘‘ Lakshmi ka janam hua hai .’’
Although the flood has pushed the Sahs to penury, the family is not angry with the river. ‘‘We are going to call her Kosia,’’ Rekha, the baby’s aunt, chirped, ‘‘We have been swept by the Kosi and she has been born on the Kosi bed,’’ The baby blinks her small eyes amid all this chatter, making her family smile.
Just two kilometres away, at a relief camp on the RMM Law College premises, two families paid rich tributes to the might
of the turbulent river as two women birth to baby girls in the camp this week. As Roopvi, a 19-year-old mother cradled her
baby, her mother-in-law declared: ‘‘ Kosi Maharani naam raakhbai (We’ll call her Empress Kosi).’’
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Bihar_newborns_being_named_after_Kosi/articleshow/3438495.cms
all 3 news articles »
Voice of America Nitish must be tried for genocide, says RJD leader
Times of India, India - 1 Sep 2008
“Sheer negligence on the part of Nitish Kumar saw the Kosi deviating from its main course, causing devastation in several districts. ...
Bihar flood victims loot relief depot NDTV.com
Deve Gowda demands technical panel on floods in Bihar Economic Times
Over five lakhs evacuated as flood situation eases marginally Hindu
Indian Express - Business Standard
all 329 news articles »
Fresh News Kosi floods: Relief work on a war footing
Times of India, India - 31 Aug 2008
NEW DELHI: The armed forces have moved into "top gear" to assist in the rescue and relief work in districts reeling under the devastation wreaked by Kosi ...
Armed forces pluck Bihar flood affected to safety IBNLive.com
Army intensifies relief operations in Bihar Hindu
‘Army made to wait for six days before deployment in Bihar’ Thaindian.com
Howrah News Service - Press Information Bureau (press release)
all 64 news articles »
BBC News Kosi threatens to swallow Katihar, Purnia
Times of India, India - 27 Aug 2008
PURNIA/ARARIA/FORBESGANJ: The turbulent Kosi, which breached the eastern afflux bund at Kusaha in Nepal and has wrought catastrophe-like havoc in Bihar's ...
Kosi river flows dangerousl Economic Times
Bihar to seek help on Kosi breach Business Standard
Kosi's fury leaves 42 dead in Bihar NDTV.com
Press Trust of India - Sify
all 411 news articles »
Greater disaster averted, says Kosi battler
Thaindian.com, Thailand - 5 hours ago
Kathmandu, Sep 3 (IANS) After a deluge that unleashed havoc in Nepal and India, the battle against the raging Saptakoshi river has finally begun to turn in
State engineers ill-equipped to plug Kosi breaches
Times of India, India - 1 Sep 2008
NEW DELHI: Plugging the breach in Kosi embankment that unleashed havoc in Bihar is proving to be a massive challenge which the state government’s engineers ...
TopNews Flood situation grim; Kosi breaches JBC canal in Purnia
Times of India, India - 31 Aug 2008
PURNIA: Spelling further trouble for lakhs of people already devastated by the floods in Bihar, the Kosi breached the Jankinagar Branch Canal (JBC) ...
Bihar floods: Kosi breaches Jankinagar canal in Purnia Thaindian.com
Flood situation deteriorates in north Bihar, Lower Assam districts Hindu
Bihar flood situation worsens NDTV.com
Zee News - India Today
all 31 news articles »
ArcelorMittal offers aid to flood-hit Bihar
Economic Times, India - 3 hours ago
... Singh had announced Rs 1000-crore aid and 1.25 lakh metric tonnes of foodgrains for the people reeling under an unprecedented deluge caused by river Kosi.
ArcelorMittal offers help for Bihar flood victims Times of India
Biharis in city struggle to reach out back home Times of India
all 4 news articles » AMS:MT
Trickle begins as Kosi curse carries on in Bihar
Expressindia.com, India - 1 Sep 2008
New Delhi, September 1 With floods in Bihar leaving some 7 lakh people stranded across five districts, the first train carrying victims reached the Capital ...
Relief as Kosi water gets outflow into Ganga
Times of India, India - 31 Aug 2008
PATNA: There seems to be some good news finally from the flood-ravaged Kosi region in Bihar. The outflow of the Kosi's water into the Ganga increased on ...
Madhepura turns ghost town as Kosi swamps everything in way
Economic Times, India - 31 Aug 2008
MADHEPURA : With thousands fleeing to escape the ever-rising waters of the Kosi river, Madhepura town in Bihar is on the verge of becoming a ghost town. ...
RJD fixes blame on govt Hindustan Times
all 9 news articles »
Curse of Kosi: Relief still not adequate
NDTV.com, India - 31 Aug 2008
Floods continue to ravage Bihar, but rescue workers with relief materials are gradually trickling in. For days, a family survived on the rooftop of a home, ...
Bihar floods: Now, Centre plays blame game
Times of India, India - 2 Sep 2008
... government being accused by the Centre of not sending a scheme for works to be executed on the damaged dams on the Nepal section of the Kosi river. ...
Curse of Kosi: Man who saw his sons drown
NDTV.com, India - 30 Aug 2008
As Bihar struggles with Kosi's wrath, it's getting difficult for people to keep their hopes alive, waiting for relief desperately. ...
Man saved 9, then watched sons drown NDTV.com
all 2 news articles »
Evacuation in flood-hit Bihar to be completed in three days
Thaindian.com, Thailand - 2 Sep 2008
Over 2.5 million people in 1598 villages spread over 15 districts have been affected by the floods triggered by the Kosi. The floods have claimed 35 lives ...
Time running out fast for people in flood-hit Madhepura
Hindu, India - 29 Aug 2008
The people from villages adjoining Murliganj had taken shelter with their cattle on the railway line Since August 20 after Kosi veered its course and ...
Boat sinks in flooded northern India, killing 20 The Associated Press
20 feared dead as Army rescue boat sinks in Bihar NDTV.com
Several feared dead as rescue boat capsizes Press Trust of India
AHN - guardian.co.uk
all 147 news articles »
Prabhu joins hands with FICCI for river connectivity
Zee News, India - 33 minutes ago
The Kosi river has created havoc in north Bihar, which is suffering one of the worst floods leaving lakhs of people homeless. After the Kosi river water ...
The Associated Press Indian military mounts mammoth flood rescue effort
The Associated Press - 21 hours ago
Only then will workers be able to plug the breach in the Kosi River that is more than a mile wide and growing. The river, which flows down from the ...
Times Now.tv Ground zero: Story of hunger & desperation
Times Now.tv, India - 13 hours ago
After seventeen days, Bihar continues to reel under the wrath of the Kosi. TIMES NOW travelled to ground zero, Purina -- the worst affected area -- to bring ...
Boats too few, victims wait on trees Calcutta Telegraph
all 2 news articles »
AFP Indian flood victims face months of destitution
AFP - 12 hours ago
Officials said work to fix the flood walls and divert the Kosi river back to its normal course cannot begin before the rainy season ends in October, ...
Caritas to feed 270000 people hit by floods in India
ReliefWeb (press release), Switzerland - 4 hours ago
Over 2500000 people in the Indian State of Bihar have had to flee the rising flood waters after the Kosi River broke its banks on 18 August following heavy ...
Caritas providing food and shelter to thousands in Bihar ReliefWeb (press release)
all 2 news articles »
Sunday, August 31, 2008
Singur Siege: Brand India, Internal corporate Imperialism and the Ways of Leftist Fascism!
Singur Siege: Brand India, Internal corporate Imperialism and the Ways of Leftist Fascism!
Troubled Galaxy Destroyed Dreams: Chapter 55
Palash Biswas
http://troubledgalaxydetroyeddreams.blogspot.com/
Imperialism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Imperialism has two meanings, one describing an action and the other describing an attitude. Most commonly it is understood in relation to Empire building, ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperialism - 49k - Cached - Similar pages
New Imperialism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
New Imperialism refers to the colonial expansion adopted by Europe's powers and, later, Japan and the United States, during the 19th and early 20th ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Imperialism - 64k - Cached - Similar pages
More results from en.wikipedia.org »
Fascism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Fascism is an authoritarian nationalist political ideology and mass movement that is concerned with notions of cultural decline or decadence, ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism - 264k - Cached - Similar pages
Definitions of fascism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
What constitutes a definition of fascism and fascist governments is a highly disputed subject that has proved complicated and contentious. ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definitions_of_fascism - 70k - Cached - Similar pages
More results from en.wikipedia.org »
Mamata suggests solution to Singur deadlock
31 Aug, 2008 [05:49 PM]
Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee said members of agitating group will meet the Governor on Sunday to press shifting of Tata Motors' ancillary units close to the Nano project site to end the deadlock in Singur.
Read More
http://www.taratv.com/west_bengal.php
Calcutta Telegraph CII condemns Singur violence
Hindustan Times, India - 10 hours ago
Press Trust Of India Apex industry chamber CII on Friday condemned violence at Singur, where Tata Motors is setting up plant for its Rs one lakh car Nano, ...
‘Singur will resonate in India’s global image’ Hindu
CII speaks tough on Singur, says it is disconcerting IBNLive.com
Industry chorus to save plant Calcutta Telegraph
all 11 news articles »
Times Now.tv Singur impasse continues, WB Governor steps in
Hindu, India - 2 hours ago
Singur-Kolkata (PTI): As the impasse over Singur issue persisted, West Bengal Governor Gopal Krishna Gandhi on Sunday stepped into the scene by suggesting a ...
Singur impasse continues, WB Governor steps in Press Trust of India
Singur crisis: WB Gov writes to Mamata Zee News
Will Mamata respond to WB Governor's call? Times Now.tv
Press Trust of India
all 11 news articles »
Business » edit
Edition:
ArgentinaAustraliaBelgiëBelgiqueBotswanaBrasilCanada EnglishCanada FrançaisChileColombiaCubaČeská republikaDeutschlandEspañaEstados UnidosEthiopiaGhanaFranceIndiaIrelandItaliaKenyaMéxicoNamibiaNederlandNew ZealandNigeriaNorgeÖsterreichPerúPortugalSchweizSouth AfricaSuisseSverigeTanzaniaUgandaTürkiyeU.K.U.S.VenezuelaZimbabwe中国版 (China)香港版 (Hong Kong)日本 (Japan)한국 (Korea)台灣版 (Taiwan)ישראל (Israel)Ελλάδα (Greece)العالم العربي (Arabic)Россия (Russia)हिन्दी (India)தமிழ்(India)
Section:
Stories 123456789
Voice of America
West Bengal wants Tata to stay: NDTV poll
NDTV.com - 1 hour ago
West Bengal supports the Tata Nano factory in Singur. This is the finding of an NDTV-GfK MODE opinion poll. Seventy five per cent of all those surveyed in urban, rural Bengal and around Singur have said that the coming of the Tatas is good for the ...
Nano will be beneficial for West Bengal: Pranab Economic Times
'Mamata's demand impossible;land can't be returned legally' Hindu
Hindustan Times - Press Trust of India - Moneycontrol.com - Sify
all 552 news articles » हिन्दी में »
Voice of America Singur will unleash fear, uncertainty in investors: Murthy
Press Trust of India, India - 3 hours ago
Bangalore, Aug 31 (PTI) Software icon NR Narayana Murthy warned today the deadlock in Singur over Tata's Nano plant following agitations will "unleash fear ...
Youth fear loss of job scope if Tatas leave Singur Economic Times
Work at Tata Motors Singur plant comes to halt Hindustan Times
No end in sight for Singur stalemate (Roundup) SINDH TODAY
NDTV.com - Hindustan Times
all 552 news articles »
Voice of America
Who killed VHP leader? Hindus, Christians divided
IBNLive.com - 10 hours ago
VIOLENCE FLASHPOINT: The Naxals have been active in these forests of Kandhamal for past many decades. What lies at the core of the tension - religious conversions, poverty or growing intolerance?
Christians may form militia for self-defence: Church leader Economic Times
Kandhamal crisis: Hatred through the cracks in Harmony Zee News
Hindustan Times - The Observer - Howrah News Service - BBC News
all 856 news articles »
Accord on Amarnath issue signed, Samiti suspends stir
Hindu - 53 minutes ago
Jammu (PTI): The more than two-month-long agitation in Jammu over the Amarnath land transfer row ended on Sunday as the state government and the group spearheading the movement signed an agreement allowing the shrine board to make use of 40 hectares of ...
Amarnath Samiti to celebrate Aug 31 annually as 'Vijay Diwas' Times of India
Samiti ends stir over land row, curfew lifted in Jammu NDTV.com
Sify - Kashmir Observer - MyNews.in - News Agency of Kashmir
all 559 news articles »
Fresh News
Revised draft exemption likely to be rejected: ACA
Hindu - 2 hours ago
Washington (PTI): The revised draft exemption for India to be presented before the Nuclear Suppliers Group has not been modulated as per the group's demands and is likely to be rejected, a top arms control specialist said on Sunday.
India jittery about this week's NSG meet NDTV.com
India circulates revised draft among NSG members Economic Times
Daily News & Analysis - Chandigarh Tribune - The Statesman - Times of India
all 411 news articles »
Separatists reject accord, sporadic incidents in Valley
Sporadic violence occurred in Kashmir with mobs, protesting among
other things the accord on the Amarnath land issue.
Bihar flood situation worsens as new areas go under water
With the water of river Kosi engulfing fresh areas in Bihar's North
Eastern 16 districts, flood situation in the state worsened.
Relocation of ancillary units will solve problem: Mamata
Mamata Banerjee said members of agitating group will meet the Governor
to press shifting of Tata Motors' ancillary units.
Deadline for Marathi signboards not extended: ThackerayOrissa: Additional security personnel deployed in Koraput‘India may open Srinagar-Muzaffarabad trade route’Two women get jail term for 'indecent acts' in Dubai
http://www.expressindia.com/ More
Brand India Ruling Hegemony led by CII and Global Market forces have come out to defend NANO launching an unprecedented Misinformation campaign.
Intelligentsia India stands rock solid with Singur Insurrection!
Meanwhile, the brand Indian Army led by C.K. Birla, Jamshyd Godrej, Sunil Bharti Mittal and S.K. Munjal were some among the army of industrialists who urged all involved to ensure that the Tatas weren’t forced to pull the plug on the project..Venu Srinivasan and K.V. Kamath, representing CII, also threw their voices behind the Nano factory through separate statements. Mukesh Ambani had articulated his support on Wednesday.
On Saturday, Kolkata intelligentsia assembled in Dhramatolla to express their support to Ms Mamata Bannerjee in her agitation in Singur! Tapasi Malik, the gang raped murdered teenager girl was once again posted on the centre of a Banner of SANHATI SAMABESH.
"There is a one line solution. Everything will be settled if the ancillary units are relocated to the land on the opposite side of the small car unit," Banerjee said from her dharna platform, a day after Governor Gopalkrishna Gandhi sent a her letter asking her to call the eight-day long stir.
Sticking to her demand that 400 acres of the land acquired for the small car project be returned to the "unwilling farmers", she said the plant could come up on 600 acres site.
"In that case both industry and agriculture will smile," she said.
SANHATI SAMABESH condemned the continuous Misinformation campaign launched by West Bengal Government, Tata and Media against Singur agitation. it exposed the Lame Excuse of Traffic Jam, deliberately created to confuse general public and subvert the Land Agitation creating artificial crisis of basic commodities in retail market. It was explained that Durgapur Express Way does not carry any Caravan of perishable Fishes, Vegetables or lifesaving drugs as focused on the media led by Anandbazar group, Star Ananda and 24 Ghanta. It was explained with graphic details that GT Road, BT Road and a ten more ways lead to Kolkata via which commodities may reach Kolkata. A resolution was passed to condemn this intriguing misinformation campaign!
Intelligentsia India demands to disclose the Agreement between the government of West Bengal and Tatas. It is never made public quoting third party involvement and violating much hyped RTI Act.
Professor Sunand Sanyal spoke,` The metro is going to witness a Grand Tamasha played by the hypocrite Left. They are organising a Grand Procession against Imperialism!’
He said,`The Anti Imperialism Demonstration led by CPIM is quite hypocritical as the Marxists in India have proved themselves the best agents of Imperialism in this geopolitics. They continued the Congress Government in the Centre to finalise the Strategic Re alliance led by United States of America as well as the Nuke Deal. They withdrew support just to dodge the Vote bank loyal!’
He further said,` Only Indigenous people like those based in Nandigram, Singur and Kalingnagar lead the genuine Anti Imperialism Anti fascism movements! The Ruling Gestapo of the Left, rather, undermines the indigenous people uprooting them from their life and livelihood and killing them mercilessly.He said,` The Left is responsible for the Internal Imperialism to enforce Marxist capitalist development for MNCs, creating Rightist Fascism!’
Dr Sanyal warned,` It will be a Himalayan blunder on the part of the Masses as well as Intelligentsia India if they chose to detach from Singur agitation due to this mischievous subversion created by the Ruling Hegemony!’
Dr Sanyal spoke so well on Internal imperialism!
It reminded me the words of Dr Manager Pandey, the eminent critic from JNU when he spoke on my novel `America Se Savdhan ‘(Be Aware of America) way back in 1996. In fact, the Novel was being published serially in Dainik Awaz published from Dhanbad and Jamshedpur simultaneously. Shramajeevi Patrakr Sangh organised a seminar on the Novel as fifty episodes were already published. Our friends Kripa Sahnkar Chaube and Arvind Chaturved was behind the event. The venue was JANSANSRA where selected audience was present and were hosted very well by Geetesh Sharma known for his book,`On the Name of religion.’ He exposed Religion long before Taslima Nasreen.
The JNU Dean warned, ` Anti Imperialism provokes Blind nationalism which blindly supports repression and annihilation of nationalities and identities until you also protest Internal Imperialism!’
The episodes of the novel were being published countrywide in little mags also and I had to answer and interact with readers on large scale. They wrote me. They encountered me face to face. They called me. Internal Imperialism was the topic on centre stage when I experimented with Interactive Novel Writing as a Creative Anti Imperialist Movement much before the Hindu Zionist White Strategic Re Alliance materialised! Much before the Nuke Deal written! Much before the war against Terrorism struck Asia and Middle east! Much Before the War zone was shifted right into our Heart in this divided bleeding Geopolitics of south Asia!
We were debating on internal Imperialism during the days of Thundering Spring which annihilated the Naxalite Uprising. The ruling Marxists were then aligned with Congress Gestapo of Siddhatrth Shankar Ray. Internal Imperialist Trend of the Marxists was exposed naked in Marichjhanpi Ethnic cleansing in January 1979.
Coincidentally, the Eye Witness of the Massacre, Sanjay Mitra, was there in the Sanhati Samabesh with CDs of ` Marichjhanpi: Tortured Humanity,’directed by Tushar Bhattachary and tele casted five times on Kolkata TV. The CD was on sale and professor Sanyal quoted the Event of First sunrise declared by then the minister of Police, culture and information in Jyoti Basu ministry, Buddhdev Bhattacharya, the Gestapo Head of the Brand India and marxists as well. Buddha declared Marichjhanpi liberated after burning the children of the indigenous refugees from Marichjhanpi, invited to settle in Marichjhanpi by no one else but Jyoti Basu. buddha declared sunrise in Marichjhanpi after dozens of the refugee women were raped and killed, their houses were burnt and their Men were shot and made the fodder for the Royal Bengal Tigers!
The Phenomenon of Marxist Internal Imperialism creating rightist Fascism was introduced by Basu and Bhattacharya long before Neo Liberalism introduced! Long before SEZ drive launched. long before the shopping malls, retail chains, chemical hubs, nuclear parks, flyovers, lock outs, retrenchment, LPG, Privatisation, disinvestment, FDI, Open Market, IT, Mobile and computer Blue revolution came fore front.
Marichjhanpi created the launching pad of internal Imperialism and Rightist Fascism in the Leftist Ruled India. It was the beginning of Nadigram and Singur.
Friends, you might remember, I have posted an On Line Petition with the Vedio of the `Marichjanpi: tortured Humanity’ in You Tube and nadigramunietd, my blog besides so many more sites long before the film was released!
Marichjhanpi genocide was committed during the time while eminent economist Dr Ashok Mitra was the finance minister in Jyoti Basu Ministry. Jatin Chakrabarti was not a rebel then. The left was combined minus CPI. Subhash Chakrabarti had offered the refugees CPIM umbrella to disassociate them the regional force, a constituent of the Left, RSP! Refugees did not oblige. Ram Chatterjee and Kiranmoy Nanda , the ministers of first Jyoti Ministry mobilised the refugees of Dandakarany to create a Vote Bank for the Left, never stood with the refugees. We the Refugees settled in UP, Uttarakhand , Assam, Bihar, Jharkhand, Hariyana, Rajsthan and anywhere in North India did not enter into the trap. Because my father, late Pulin Kumar Biswas did not believe the Bengali Brahmin Marxists and were quite aware of the Marxist Legacy of betrayal and Hypocrisy. he learnt it in Dhimri Block Peasant uprising in 1958. he felt it In Assam in 1960, where he landed to rescue his brothers, the Refugees.
The other parties habitual to enjoy the benefits being in Government with minimum mass base, Forward Block, RSP, SP and so on, supported the Genocide culture and the Gestapo.
Yes, it was the time just after the Tebhaga. Just after the Food Movement. just after the Bangladesh Liberation. Just after the complete surrender, disintegration and repression of Naxalbari!
Yes, it was the time while the Left front Government was engaged in much hyped Land Reforms and Rural Development. The Marxists were heading the mass movements of students, women, indigenous communities, trade unions, peasants and workers. But the Marxists never hesitated to kill the Class Enemies, the refugees, the Indigenous People. The other left and secular parties were silent.
Civil Society was silent.
Intelligentsia India was silent.
The sage of Internal imperialism continues with fullest Volume!
We have witnessed Operation Blue Star!
We have seen ram Janma Bhoomi Movement.
We bear the Military Rule in Kashmir and Entire North East under AFPSA umbrella! We never resisted. We never did address the Nationalities as a nation! We always supported the merciless Military repression of Identities and Nationalities. It is Blind nationalism provoked by Internal imperialism as well as Rightist fascism. So, entire India is fielded against Tamilnadu sometimes. Sometimes it is any state of the North east Isolated, alienated! Some times it is Punjab. Sometimes the communities belonging to minorities are targeted. The Sikhs felt the Heat. The Kashmir People could never liberate themselves from the bondage of second class doubtful citizenship. Tamils and Dravids nevre became the part of the Nation as they happen to be most Vocal nationalities empowered, organised and enlightened. We never cared to know south India! WE press that the People from south should speak Hindi. They, of course learnt Hindi. Kearla has always been a strong base for Hindi. Even Manipur happens to be a strong base of Hindi. it follows the legacy of the philosophy of love introduced by Krishna consciousness as a mass movement against castism by Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.
But would we ask ourselves how many of us in North India cared to learn a single south Indian language!
How many of us know Manipur and its culture!
How many of us know any Nationality in North East!
How many of us sympathise with the Kashmiri people!
How many of us know Jharkhand, Chhattisgargh, Bidarbha, Telengana, Uttarakhand and Gorkhaland, the regions of discrimination inherent!
We have been witnessing the Hindutva Resurrection since 1984 Which is strengthened further by Neo Liberalism and strategic re alliance with Zionism and US Corporate War economy Imperialism and War against Terrorism!
We have witnessed the demolition of Babri Mosque and following Nationwide riots!
We have also witnessed Gujarat Genocide.
Irony is this that the Marxists were most vocal against internal Imperialism, Fascism and United states of America. Though it supported the Soviet aggression on Afghanistan! Though it never opposed the sacred cow, soviet socialist imperialism!
Marichjhanpi, Keshpur or Nanur could not expose the Marxist Masks.
But Nandigram and Singur have succeeded to expose the Ugly faces of the ruling Marxists and proved that the Marxists are also responsible for internal Imperialism and rightist Fascism as the run blindly on the super Highway of Marxist Capitalism projecting Brand India, devastating Indigenous production system and killing our people, the indigenous communities uprooting them from life and livelihood!
Mahashweta Devi has declared to give up writing Novels for Puja Festival as he is engaged in mass mobilisation supporting the Indigenous insurrections in Nandigram, Singur and Kalingnagra!
Bibhas Chakrabarti has rightly written that the Marxists are quite unworthy Rulers as they tend to work as agents of MNCs, Corporates, Builders, Promoters and Mafia!
The director of `Animal Farm’ , Shaoli Mitra exposes the phenomenon of internal Imperialism so well.
Sahity Academy Awarded Writer known Nationwide for his poetry, ` Ei Mritu Uptyaka Amar Desh Noi’( This Valley of Death is never my Country’) exposed Brand India and MNC raj. He questioned the justification of the logic of Nano! If TATAs go, West Bengal is going to face a Doom`s day. He blasted the theory and the Illusion of Nano!
Former Land commissioner of Jyoti Basu Government, responsible for Land Reforms, Debbrata Bandopaddhyaya asserted,`CPIM`s Red Flag does not belong to Hay Market who won the classic battle with their blood to ensure working hour for Eight years!’
He alleged,` It is a red flag colored with the blood of Indigenous communities fighting for their land, livelihood and life in Nandigarm and Singur!’
He said,` The interests of Brand India, CII or Tats are not public interest. The Land Acquisition Act was misused to benefit Tatas. The land acquisition is illegal!’
He suggested the solution for Singur Stand Off,` Just Cancel the acquisition Notification an d return the Land!’
He described the episode involving Tapasi Malik!
Meeratun Nahar, the eminent educationist, Dilip Chakrabarti, Human Right activist Sujat Bhadra, and Dr Anoop Mandal addressed the SANHATI SAMABESH. he exposed the whole process of Industrialisation!
Dr Mandal presented graphic details of the dismal condition in West Bengal Industries. He said that Fifty Six thousand factories have been closed in Left rule . What happened to the land owned by those closed factories. This Massive Land Property might be used for Industrialisation. He discussed Food security, Starvation, privatisation, disinvestment, Unemployment, Health Care, Price rise and economy under Left rule.
He also shared his experience as a member of the Medical team treating the wounded, gang raped Women of Nandigram.
On behalf of Doctors, health workers, Nurses and Junior Doctors as well as medical students he pledged support to Indigenous Insurrections against Internal Imperialism and rightist Fascism of the Marxist Gestapo!
Meher sent this mail:
This appeal is about Sinngur. It was released to the press
at a rally for singur in Kolkata.
Mahasveta Devi, Samar Bagchi , Sumit Sarkar, Tanika Sarkar, Sumit Chowdhury, Aditi Chowdhury, and myself as the drafter signed it last nite
Saoli Mitra, Dr Aseem Rai Chaudhuri, Dipanjan Rai Chaudhuri, Sunanda sanyal,Debabrata Badyopadhyay, Ladli Mukherjee, Saoli Mitra, Gautam Sen, Sabyasachi Deb, Nilanja Datta, Joya Mitra and others whose names have also done so.
Very many more are likely to when friends like you approach them.
please circulate the Appeal as widely as you can. get it published if
possible. do what you like, but get the message out. acknowledge my name as
the appeal's drafter, or don't if that is more likely to work.
the message is the important thing. .
Thanks,
meher
*Appeal To Fellow Citizens*
* *
*The May 2008 Panchayat Elections have been historic. The people of West
Bengal have spoken out, as never before. All political parties, those that
lost and those that gained, now know what the people demand. *
* *
*They demand an immediate full stop to the devious and shabby ways that have
dominated politics in the State for much too long. *
* *
*They are not against change but demand an end to change done above their
heads and in secret by a nexus of political parties and vested interests. *
* *
*Change seeking shall henceforth be a process that intimately involves the
people. Those who want change must be prepared to begin by seeking the open
approval of the people concerned and, having got their approval, must then
be equally prepared to accept a central role for the people, as
ever-vigilant monitors of the implementation process. *
* *
*That being so, we must: *
* *
*i) **Support the ongoing and just struggles of the people
of Singur against the forcible occupation of their lands; *
* *
*ii) **Reject the secret deal between the CPI (M) dominated
West Bengal Government and the Tata Motor Company - both of who claim to be
benign and people loving - that led to that occupation. *
* *
*iii) **Demand that any resolution of the dispute surrounding
the Nano Car factory at Singur shall: *
* *
*a) **Start with an open admission, by the State Government, of the
series of mistakes that it made when it acquired 997.11 acres of land, both
when it used an unjust law that should have no place in the independent
Republic of India, and when it used criminal means - deceit, coercion and
the beating up of unarmed and innocent protestors, mostly common folk, the
greater part of who were women – to enforce that law. *
* *
*b) **Continue with a genuine attempt, by all involved political
parties and civil society organizations to openly negotiate a settlement to
the impasse that meets the just demands of the people of Singur. *
* *
*c) **Accept both the people of Singur and the migrant workers who have
been part of the economy that Singur's multicrop agriculture has generated
for years, as integral partners in those negotiations because it is their
land and their livelihoods that are at stake, whether as land owners or
bargadars or bhag chaashis or farm laborers. *
* *
*iv) Appeal to the alert and intelligent people of West Bengal and
India to come together once more. The gains that they have made in
consequence of the many demonstrations of discontent that they were witness
to, and participants in, for almost two years, not only on the streets and
fields of Nandigram and Singur, and on the streets of Kolkata and other
urban centers all over the state, but also in similar places elsewhere in
the country should not be lost when negotiations happen. *
* *
*The people of West Bengal want radical change. They must have it. *
* *
*Signed, *
* *
* *
* *
Read this mail circulated by friends in the civil society, kolkata:
Agitation for urge to return of the excess lands acquisitioned for Nano car factory at Singur
Readers r aware that the Bengal govt. has, in its anxiousness to help a private industrialist to set up a factory n make profit at taxpayers' expense thro' practically free supply of prime agricultural land at Singur, of infrastructure, of use of a river being used by the villagers, huge security personnel at site at Govt. expense and long-term loan with a negligble rate of interest and additional lands at other parts of Kolkata to faciltate Tatas' additional profit through promoting, making an agreement with the Tatas contents of which r being kept secret not only from the public but even from members of the Govt.'s own cabinet of Ministers, have stooped so low an inhuman, as to take recourse to even using police, cadres and hired mercenaries to murder, rape and throw away the farmers from their lands they have refused to part with and to accept compensation. Naturally these immoral and cruel acts by the Govt and the Ruling Party (claiming to be Communists, i.e. 'pro-poor') has evoked huge upswell of mass condemnation. The Chief Minister shamelessly admits that 'he did not know that the land was so fertile".But at the same time he says that what has been done cannot be undone. That those who r opposing the deal to help the Tatas, r against indusrialisation n stand in the way of 'progress' of the state. (So there is no punishment for the 'mistake' which has resulted in loss of prime agricultural land from being available to produce multiple crops to feed the state in the prevailing situation of scarcity and of high cost of foodgrains n vegetables, and for the loss of lives, raping of woman, unrest in civil society. For the sake of compromising with the situation, the civil society demands that the factory can be set up in 600 acres, but the 400 acres of land procured beyond the requirement of the factory proper, must be returned to the farmers who have not agreed to part with their lands and refused to accept the compensation cheques. But the Govt is adamant that the 400 acres of land cannot be so returned. To press for this just demand (of return of 400 acres), for the last 6 days, stages at different locations around the site have been built and Sit-in demonstrations are being arranged, by the opposition political parties, aggrieved farmers and large section of members of the civil society including social activists, intelligentsia, students and others. Now the Govt and the CPI-M manipulated the situation so as to create a traffic snarl at the highways near the site and at the same time unleashing a huge false propaganda to create public opinion against the agitation, claiming that urgent supplies,medicines, perishables are being spoiled being inside the trucks caught in the traffic snarl. A person also was found by the party to file a Public Interest Litigation in Kolkata High Court to intervene in the hold up in traffic. The High Court has today directed the NHAI(National Highways Authority of India) to take action to clear the roads for movement of traffic and to take help of the state govt . The Court has however said that this should be done without use of force. The Court also agreed to the opposition lawyer's suggestion that the identity of the person filing the PIL should be discovered (whether he was a genuine person).Pl find in ther attachment the report by investigating journalist of the most respectable and non-partisan newspaper The Statesman, which goes to prove clearly that the state govt., the pliant police and the ruling CPI-M party have manipulated and created an unnecessary traffic snarl to disrepute the agitation movement.
‘India, US need to increase trade scope’
Our Bureau
Chennai, Aug. 26 India and the US should pay special attention to infrastructure, financial services, bilateral investments and renewable energy to increase trade opportunities, according to US Commercial Consul, Ms Aileen Crowe Nandi.
Though the bilateral trade between India and the US is growing by leaps and bounds and crossed $50 billion last year, there are more opportunities that need to be tapped, she said.
Speaking at a seminar on ‘Doing business with USA’, organised by Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), Ms Nandi said there are a few challenges that need to be addressed to realise the potential. A delegation on renewable energy would be visiting India next month, which would help both countries identify possibilities for cooperation.
On their experiences in doing business in India, representatives from Ford India and Caterpillar India had similar points of view. While appreciating the conducive business atmosphere, especially in Tamil Nadu, where their companies have manufacturing facilities, Mr Nigel Wark, Executive Director (marketing, sales and service) Ford India, and Mr Larry Stacker, General Manager (supply chain), Caterpillar India, expressed concern about infrastructure, rail connectivity, storage facilities in port and employable manpower. The Vice-Consul of the US Consular Office in Chennai, Mr Paul Hinshaw, said the number of visa applications has been growing at the rate of 20 per cent every year. Chennai processed the largest number of H1B (temporary worker) visas last year.
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/2008/08/27/stories/2008082750852100.htm
IIPM to come up at Rajarhat
Statesman News Service KOLKATA, Aug. 30: The Indian Institute of Planning and Management (IIPM) a management institute is contemplating to open up their, business school at Rajarhat. Speaking about th
‘Poor coal quality causing power cuts’
Snehamoy Chakraborty BAKRESWAR, Aug. 30: Power production at various units of the Bakreswar Thermal Power Project (BTPP) may be affected soon as the Eastern Coalfield Limited (ECL) has been providin
Industry push eases out literacy drive
Biswabrata Goswami TAMLUK, Aug. 30: The drive for increasing literacy is losing ground in Midnapore East as Continuing Education Centres (CEC) have remained non-operational due to the political turmoi
Slain caretaker’s kin threaten to gherao SP’s office
Statesman News Service MIDNAPORE, Aug. 30: The parents of Prasun Adhikari (27), the slain caretaker of Ritz Bengal Lodge have threatened to stage a sit-in demonstration at Midnapore West SP's office
Priya raps ‘blockade’
KOLKATA, Aug.30: While deploring the blockade on Durgapur expressway Union minister and the state Congress president Mr Priya Ranjan Dasmunshi today urged the state government to call for an all party
Centre seeks to distance itself from Singur
NEW DELHI, Aug. 29: The Centre today sought to distance itself from the ongoing stand-off between the West Bengal government and the Trinamul Congress over the Tata’s small car project in Singur sayin
BRIEFS
Suchpur trial date SURI, Aug. 30: The trial for the Suchpur massacre in which 11 landless farmers were hacked to death, allegedly by CPI-M cadres on 27 July 2000, is scheduled to start on 5, 6 and 10
Drunk security guards molest woman at CMCH
KOLKATA Aug 30: Tension ran high at Calcutta Medical College and Hospital (CMCH) tonight after some drunken security guards at the emergency ward allegedly tried to molest a woman visiting a relative
Sick of politics, engineers quit KMC in hordes
Statesman News Service KOLKATA, Aug. 30: Higher salaries in private sector and in state government service are luring Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) engineers away. Thirteen engineers have alr
Govt hints at crackdown on agitators
Statesman News Service
KOLKATA, Aug. 30: The state government is contemplating action to rein in the agitators at Singur, indicated the commerce and industries minister, Mr Nirupam Sen even as work at the Nano plant remained stalled for the second consecutive day with Tata Motors saying the situation is still not conducive to resume work at their plant.
Speaking on the sidelines of a programme organised by the Union Bank Employees Association today, Mr Sen said: “Ms Mamata Banerjee's has not even heeded the court order that asked her to clear obstruction of the NH-2. If this is the way existing laws are violated the state government would have to contemplate action to uphold the law . . . If the court asks us tomorrow to take action to restore normalcy in the area, we will have to take necessary action.”
He however, did not clarify whether the action would be to smoothen the traffic flow on Durgapur Expressway or to remove the agitators altogether. He reminded that the Calcutta High Court had upheld land acquisition in Singur and the matter was pending in Supreme Court but “till then they abide by the High Court verdict.”
“We have repeatedly urged her to sit and discuss the matter. She had promised us that her agitation would be peaceful but she has deviated from her promise too,” Mr Sen added. Several Tata Motors employees and contractual labourers were detained inside the project area when supporters of the Singur Krishi Jomi Raksha Committee blocked gate number 4 of the project site on Thursday evening.
So far, other than issuing appeals to the Trinamul chief, Miss Mamata Banerjee to end her agitation and sit at the discussion table, the state government had refused to take any action to prevent traffic snarls on the NH-2. However, it is evident the government received a shot in the arm after the Calcutta High Court ordered the National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) to take necessary action to ensure free movement of traffic on the Durgapur Expressway.
Claiming that people of West Bengal were not supporting Ms Banerjee's movement, the commerce and industry minister said: “It is the state's image that has suffered because of this agitation. We have already told Ms Banerjee that we are ready to speak with the displaced people and see to it that their interests are upheld.”
Miss Banerjee meanwhile said she had received a letter from the Governor, whose contents and her reaction she would disclose tomorrow.
She added the CPI-M has been caught in their own game plan. She (Continued from page 1)
said that CPI-M has tried to discredit the agitation by instigating the people on the plea that it had held up trucks carrying food items but their plans have been thoroughly exposed.
Actually police at the behest of CPI-M district leadership put up a blockade at Palsit, 65 km from the spot and another at Dankuni, 20 km from here. “It was CPI-M's plan to obstruct our supporters which failed thoroughly,” she said.
She said: "Why should we block the road? Are we fools? If we had blocked the road our supporters would have been obstructed from coming to the site.'' During the day, Mr Avadesh Kumar, project director NHAI, met three Trinamul Congress leaders and the district administration after the High Court directed NHAI to ensure movement of vehicles along NH2.
Miss Banerjee said that NHAI authorities have expressed their satisfaction that TMC did not obstruct the road. But NHAI authorities and the district administration are learnt to be in a dilemma about allowing heavy vehicles to run at night for fear of an accident. Asked about his observation, Mr Kumar said, "I've sent the report to my headquarters at Delhi. I'm waiting for their orders.''
Home secretary Mr A M Chakrabarti said that Mr Kumar had sought help from the district administration but did not specify his demand. He, however, said that both the state and the Centre would have to implement the High Court order.
Police crackdown
The police resorted to lathi charge on the Trinamul Congress activists at Chandra crossing near Asansol on NH-2 this afternoon when the party men blocked the road. Three of the party men sustained injuries and were hospitalised. The agitators blocked NH-2 for 15 minutes protesting the arrest of party activist Joydeb Karmakar, a resident of Kantagoria village in Jamuria PS area.
Karunanidhi: Putting an end to speculations that Tata might opt for Tamil Nadu if it relocates the Nano manufacturing unit from Singur, Chief Minister M Karunanidhi today said there was no move from either side in this regard, reports PTI.
http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=1&theme=&usrsess=1&id=220380
Industry chorus to save plant
OUR BUREAU
Ratan Tata with CK Birla. File picture
Aug. 29: A blizzard of appeals rose from Indian industry today to save the Nano project in Singur, prompting some to hear a note of foreboding in the unusual crescendo.
C.K. Birla, Jamshyd Godrej, Sunil Bharti Mittal and S.K. Munjal were some among the army of industrialists who urged all involved to ensure that the Tatas weren’t forced to pull the plug on the project..Venu Srinivasan and K.V. Kamath, representing CII, also threw their voices behind the Nano factory through separate statements. Mukesh Ambani had articulated his support on Wednesday.
Rarely has Indian industry issued such a raft of statements on a single investment project, fuelling some to speculate that the fate of the Singur plant is hanging by a thin thread and only a contingency could have prompted the chorus.
A factor common to several of the statements was an apprehension that a Tata pullout would have its repercussions not just in Bengal but across the country.
The most striking statement of the day was that of C.K. Birla, the Hindustan Motors chairman, whose vocal endorsement brings together “Tata and Birla” — once a catch-all phrase to describe the entire Indian private sector.
“Tata’s Nano project is a prestigious project for India and for the state of West Bengal.… It would be unfortunate if issues other than economic and social come into play and force the Tata management to consider pulling out from Singur,” said Birla.
Mittal of Bharti, a Tata rival in telecom, said: “The Tatas pulling out of West Bengal will be unfortunate for India.… Immediate political dialogue to find a solution towards keeping the project in West Bengal is imperative.”
“If the House of Tatas, known for its values and care for society, can face such resistance, the much-needed fresh wave of industrialisation in the country would suffer,” he added.
Jamshyd Godrej, the chairman and managing director of Godrej and Boyce, said: “Nano’s moving out would be a setback for not just West Bengal but the entire country. It is very unfortunate that the entire project is facing a political situation which it does not warrant…. The political parties involved must do their best to ensure that the concerns and issues of all the stakeholders are kept in mind, including the companies in question and the original owners of the land.”
Hero Corporate Service chairman S.K. Munjal, too, stressed the national cost. “It is in the interest of both West Bengal and India that the Tata Nano project is not moved at this stage. Withdrawal of the project will severely affect West Bengal’s image, and it certainly won’t do India’s image any good. Political parties must rise above partisan lines….”
He said the “investing en-tity has a responsibility to take care of the interests of all stakeholders, including people who are displaced or re-employed”.
Like Birla, Munjal spoke of the Tatas’ credentials. “Indeed, given their level of social commitment, I have no doubt that the Tatas are fully aware of their responsibilities in Singur as they have demonstrated in many of their companies.”
The Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers said it would like to see an early resolution of the tangle. It warned that “global attention” was on the developments as the Nano was seeking to challenge all conventional theories about car making.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1080830/jsp/bengal/story_9764415.jsp
Englishmen and zamindars
Oil paintings in the collection of the British Indian Association have been restored. Picture by Pabitra Das
Few if any had noticed the demolition of the old building that housed the British Indian Association in the street named after it a few years ago. The street has already been renamed after Abdul Hamid and a brand new office building has come up in place of the old one.
The association occupies several rooms on the third floor of this building at the head of Barretto Lane. The association still possesses a rich collection of books and paintings and other artefacts, among which are the portraits of local Indian dignitaries who were association members, and two busts of Radhakanta Deb and Kristo Das Paul, besides a priceless collection of books that needs to be looked after.
The association was originally a political organisation that had a role in the creation of the Indian National Congress, whose early meetings were held in this building.
From a political organisation it became a landholders’ organisation, although it also took up causes that affected Indians in general. After the abolition of the zamindari system in the early 1950s, its functions may have been curtailed but over the years it has become a repository of valuable research material.
About 20 years before the establishment of the British Indian Association, Dwarkanath Tagore, Prasanna Kumar Tagore, Radhakanta Deb, Ramkamal Sen, Bhabani Charan Mitra and the then editor of The Englishman had formed the Zamindari Association in 1831. It was later renamed Landholders’ Society and was considered “the first organisation of Bengal with a distinct political object.” Englishmen and Indian landholders met here “on an equal footing”. But after Dwarkanath passed away the society too was as good as dead.
A few years later, William Adam, who became friends with Raja Rammohun Roy during his visit to India, decided to take up India’s cause on returning to England. He was the moving spirit behind the formation of the British Indian Society in 1839. George Thompson, who was also involved in its formation, went on to help create the Bengal British India Society. It was meant to further the interests of all classes of Indians through its recommendations and measures which had to be “consistent with pure loyalty to the person and government of the reigning sovereign of the British dominions”.
Indians felt alienated when Europeans vehemently opposed John Elliot Drinkwater’s efforts in 1849 to bring all British-born subjects of the crown under the jurisdiction of the local law courts. The government was forced to withdraw the “Black bill,” as the Europeans called it. Thereafter, the Landholders’ Society and the Bengal British India at a meeting held on October 29, 1851, at Kasaitola (subsequently Bentinck Street) decided to form the British Indian Association by merging the two bodies to highlight the grievances of Indians.
The first committee of the association was composed of Radhakanta Deb, Kalikrishna Deb, Debendranath Tagore, Digambar Mitra, Prasanna Kumar Tagore, Peary Chand Mitra and Sambhunath Pandit. Besides rajas and maharajas and zamindars, Derozians and the intellectual aristocracy of the Bengal Presidency also held important positions on the committee. Traders and businessmen were also members. But membership was strictly confined to Indians.
The objects of the association “were related partly to improvements in the local administration of the country and partly to the system of Indian government laid by Parliament”. Joteendra Mohan Tagore and Joykrishna Mukherji enabled the association to have a home at 18 Raneemoody Gully, whose name was later changed to British Indian Street.
The association had “an all-India outlook” and in a petition to the Parliament in UK, it criticised the British government for not allowing the Indians “the smallest share in the administration of the affairs of this country.” Among its demands was “the separation of the Legislature from the Executive, and the inclusion of some Indian members in the Legislature.” It supported the move to bring all British-born subjects under the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts. It welcomed the formation of the Mohammedan Association of Calcutta in 1856 as the association wanted to give new shape to the Indian polity.
During the Indigo Rebellion of 1859-60, the association sympathised with the ryots and pleaded with the government to appoint a commission of inquiry to solve the problems of indigo cultivation. The association tried to impinge on social and living conditions by suggesting measures on epidemics, floods, famines, taxation, the practice of Sati, burning ghats and property and inheritance.
It championed the causes of the Indian people at a time when there was no strong political body in the country. The association in 1874 “suggested that public opinion in India should be taken into consideration before enactment of any legislation concerning India”. The association gave the people the first lesson in the art of fighting constitutionally for their rights and giving expression to their opinions. All bills were sent to the association for comment, some of which were quite incisive.
The second meeting of the Indian National Congress was held in the association building on December 28, 1886. M.K. Gandhi, Bar-at-Law from Durban, visited the association in 1891 to draw the viceroy’s attention to the plight of Indians in South Africa.
Now that there aren’t any landholders the association will support research work with its meagre funds, said I.P. Singh Roy, the honorary president of the organisation. The library which contains important books, some dating back to 1783 like Ayeen Akbery in translation and others belonging to the 19th century and early 20th century, will be preserved. Many of its collection of large oil paintings have been competently restored by Narayan Srivastava. In our times, British Indian Association can survive as an institution promoting excellence.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1080831/jsp/calcutta/story_9753086.jsp
Govt allays industry’s fears on slowdown
No slowdown signs: The Finance Minister, Mr P. Chidambaram, and the President, Confederation of Indian Industry, Mr K.V. Kamath, at an interactive session with CEOs of select CII member-companies in the Capital on Tuesday. - Kamal Narang
Our Bureau
New Delhi, Aug. 26 India Inc has demanded proactive solutions from the Government on its concerns of increase in interest rates and signs of slowdown in consumer demand, with exorbitant interest cost impinging on its future investments.
The Finance Minister, Mr P. Chidambaram, however, brought little cheer on the interest rate front during his meeting with select group of chief executives of CII member companies here on Tuesday even as he made it clear that industry’s fears on signs of slowdown in demand were misplaced, sources privy to the meeting said.
Strong on schemes
Mr Chidambaram is understood to have asserted that the Government was pumping money into the economy through its spending on various schemes and that this would take care of the demand issue. The Finance Minister maintained that demand was quite strong and that credit growth was stronger than what the Government and the RBI want it to be, industry sources said.
RBI to decide on rates
On interest rates, Mr Chidambaram conveyed that there was no scope for the Government to look at interest rates and that RBI would do what it wants on this front.
The Finance Minister also ruled out cut in taxes, noting that this would result in higher borrowings for the Government and thereby impacting interest rates. Mr Chidambaram expressed confidence that the economy would be on track in the first half of 2009-10 and that inflation would soften by mid-November when the base effect is likely to wear-off.
At the meeting, the CII President, Mr K.V. Kamath, said that even though the current pipeline of investments remained intact, fresh investment proposals were being affected by the rising costs of inputs, rising interest costs and signs of slowdown in demand.
On the positive side, Mr Kamath said that there was no problem with liquidity and that banks currently have sufficient funds, although the availability of long-term funds remain an issue.
The Finance Minister agreed that there could be some holding back on new projects due to high interest rates, but pointed out that credit off-take across sectors continued to be strong. He said that as long as inflation continued to be high, it would be difficult to moderate interest rates.
http://www.blonnet.com/2008/08/27/stories/2008082752010100.htm
Oil decontrol on the boil
OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT
Mumbai, Aug. 29: The Reserve Bank of India today urged the government to allow greater decontrol of petroleum tariffs, rationalise taxes and ensure a gradual pass-through of prices to avoid a sharp spike in headline inflation.
“In view of the large dependence on crude oil imports, limiting the adverse impact of higher international oil prices would require adopting strategies of greater decontrol of petroleum product pricing with targeted subsidies, rationalisation of applicable taxes and duties to appropriate levels, and gradual but regular pass-through of prices to consumers so as to avoid the risk of large one-off adjustments in headline inflation,” the central bank said in its annual report for 2007-08.
Against the almost 134-per-cent increase in the prices of international crude oil (Indian basket) from $56.6 per barrel in February last year to $132.3 per barrel in July, the RBI said the prices of petrol and diesel had increased only about 14 per cent since February 2007 and, therefore, there remained a large overhang of pass-through from past increases in international crude oil prices.
The RBI also said issuing oil bonds to state-owned refiners would impact public debt. It said the interest expenditure on these bonds would widen revenue and fiscal deficits and hurt financial markets.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1080830/jsp/business/story_9764005.jsp
Tata Steel shifts gear at Kalinganagar
OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT
Muthuraman in Calcutta on Friday. A Telegraph picture
Calcutta, Aug. 29: Tata Steel has finally started work at its Kalinganagar project in Orissa.
B. Muthuraman, managing director of the company, said preliminary work had begun a few weeks back. The company hopes to start production in three years.
“We started construction in a small way. Boundary wall is being erected, structural fabrication is being done,” Muthuraman said on the sidelines of the Tinplate annual general meeting in Calcutta.
Tata Steel is running way behind schedule at Kalinganagar as about 700 families refused to vacate the site.
However, some of the families have moved out and work has started on the land where they used to reside. The affected families had even taken part in construction work. “They are the people who are doing the work,” Muthuraman said.
The company has placed orders worth Rs 6,500 crore for the first phase of the six-million-tonne plant.
On allocation of iron ore mines for the project, Muthuraman said the state government would give its recommendation to the Centre in the next two to three months.
Tinplate recast
Muthuraman said Tinplate planned to restructure its balance sheet, though he declined to give any details.
Tinplate director Koushik Chatterjee said the aim of restructuring was to ensure that the company could take up bigger projects on its own.
The process could be completed by next fiscal, he said.
On Tinplate merging with parent Tata Steel, Muthuraman said he could not comment.
He said last fiscal was an unusual year for the company because of an increase in the prices of raw materials.
“Globally, most other tinplate firms suffered losses. Corus (a Tata Steel entity) closed its tinplate facility. Given the scenario, Tinplate has done well,” he said.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1080830/jsp/business/story_9763854.jsp
Commodity prices in unwind mode
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The role of speculative funds lay in amplifying supply-demand mismatches, where they existed, and buying up large chunks of the commodity on paper without ever taking delivery and thereby disproportionately jacking up prices.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
— G. Krishnaswamy
India has managed to relatively insulate itself from the speculative froth built up in global commodity markets.
Harish Damodaran
From all available indications, it looks as though the extended global bull-run in commodities is over. Since March-April, there has been a falling trend in prices of base metals such as copper, lead, nickel and zinc, alongside an easing of wheat, rice and palm oil from their peaks. The past few weeks have seen a similar unwinding in oil, gold, corn and soybean. The speculative frenzy that had over the last couple of years launched commodities into stratosphere appears t o be finally cooling off.
Table 1 shows the extent of rise in world prices of 15 commodities from December 2005 to July 2006. These range from 36 per cent in aluminium and cotton to over 370 per cent for coal. The only exception has been sugar, which actually recorded a drop, for reasons to be explained later.
The dollar slide
The huge price increases in most commodities have partly had to do with the dollar’s decline as a global reserve currency — a reflection of the growing loss of US manufacturing competitiveness and also the undermining of its geopolitical hegemony following the costly war (both in monetary as well as foreign policy terms) waged in Iraq. While in December 2005, a dollar fetched 0.84 euros, in July 2008 it averaged a mere 0.63 euros.
What this means is that the 124 per cent dollar-denominated jump in crude petroleum prices between December 2005 and July 2008 was only worth 68 per cent in euro terms. Likewise, the 99.6 per cent and 160 per cent rise in dollar prices of wheat and corn translated into less than 50 and 95 per cent, respectively when measured in euros. But even after discounting for the dollar’s precipitous free-fall, the fact remains that never before in history have commodity prices surged on as widespread a scale as they have done in the recent period.
This is evident from the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) indices of primary commodity prices in SDRs or special drawing rights. The latter, representing a basket of currencies (dollar, euro, yen and pound sterling), corrects for any distortions arising from the dollar’s vicissitudes and enables one to gauge better the ‘real’ increase in global commodity prices.
The IMF’s ‘all primary commodities’ price index in SDRs, which averaged 100 in 2005, amounted to 197.7 in July 2008. The ‘food’, ‘metals’ and ‘energy’ indices went up correspondingly to 160.3, 170.2 and 224.1. Commodity prices have, on the whole then, doubled within a space of two-and-a-half years and are now apparently entering the next ‘Great Unwind’ stage.
Distinct ‘asset class’
This extreme price volatility is mainly an outcome of commodities emerging as a distinct ‘asset class’ on a par with equities, bonds, currencies and related financial derivatives — making them attractive to not just the direct stakeholders (farmers, processors, wholesalers, shippers, etc) but to a range of institutional investors from hedge funds, pension plans and exchange-traded index funds.
For these investors — the big funds based on the S&P Goldman Sachs Commodity Index and the Deutsche Bank Liquid Commodity Index were, in fact, floated only in 2006 — commodity contracts are not simply hedging tools against adverse future price movements, but like any other financial instrument. The big difference though is that while the impact of rising (or falling) stock prices is largely limited to the shareholders concerned, the rise or fall in corn prices also affects farmers and households who are not investors in these contracts.
On the other hand, price volatility is a sine qua non for investors having no direct stakes in the underlying commodity either as producer or consumer. The so-called fundamental factors — supply disruptions due to unfavourable weather conditions, diversion of arable land for bio-fuels or the assumed demand pressures from China and India — merely serve as pretexts for pouring in or pulling-out monies and sending prices way beyond their intrinsic values.
Speculative forces
In late March, the Economics Editor of Barron’s, Gene Epstein, estimated that index funds accounted for 40 per cent of bullish bets on commodities. “The speculative juices are even more plentiful — nearly 60 per cent of bullish positions — if you count the bets placed by traditional commodity ‘pools’”, he wrote, while predicting a 30-50 per cent drop in commodity prices in the months ahead (that seems to be happening now).
It is this speculative element alone that can explain how international palm oil prices touched $1,350-1,400 a tonne levels in March 2008 — a more than 100 per cent year-on-year jump — and subsequently slid below $750 a tonne. This is not to say there were no fundamental triggers, such as edible palm oil being converted into bio-diesel and its prices getting linked to crude petroleum.
The role of speculative funds, however, lay in amplifying supply-demand mismatches, where they existed, and buying up large chunks of the commodity on paper without ever taking delivery and thereby disproportionately jacking up prices.
In sugar, it was the opposite. The huge production glut, especially in India, meant there was little fund buying interest in the commodity. Instead, they sold heavily, so much so that raw sugar fell from over 18 cents a pound in February 2006 to nine cents by May 2007.
Relatively insulated
India, on its part, has managed to relatively insulate itself from the speculative froth built up in global commodity markets. The domestic wholesale price indices (WPI) for most commodities have risen by a much lower extent than world levels (Table 2). Again, a weak dollar has helped, with the greenback falling from Rs 45.65 in December 2005 to Rs 42.84 in July 2008.
But the greater contribution has come from government policies. These have extended from administrative vetoes on price hikes (as in petro-products) to tinkering with import duties (edible oils) and ban on exports and futures trading (wheat and rice), which have prevented international price pressures from transmitting into the domestic market.
In other words, a forced de-globalisation of sorts. Only in rubber and cotton have domestic prices gone up more than world prices. And this has been courtesy exports, benefiting Indian farmers at the expense of tyre manufacturers and textile millers.
What’s in store?
What now? Well, if present trends are any guide and the sell-off by funds in commodities continues, the shoe could well be on the other foot. The Government may, for instance, have to re-impose Customs duties on edible oils to protect domestic oilseeds growers against any downturn during the ensuing kharif harvest season.
In sugar, the global supply position is tightening (this time, due to India’s considerably lower cane crop); but in the absence of fund buying interest, prices may not spurt the way they would have done a year ago.
As far as oil goes, in the event of crude falling below $100 a barrel and the Government unlikely to rollback diesel and petrol prices to their earlier levels, the public sector oil marketing companies could even see their fortunes turnaround.
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/2008/08/27/stories/2008082750520900.htm
The Doha Round impasse
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Though no country wants the multilateral trade negotiation and dispute settlement mechanism of the WTO to break down, much of the world economy is in serious trouble and in no mood for trade liberalisation. Thus, the chances of any real breakthrough in the Doha Round talks do not look bright at this moment, says ALOK RAY.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commerce Minister, Mr Kamal Nath… Let down by failure of best efforts.
Despite nearly three dozen trade and commerce ministers meeting at Geneva last month to save the Doha Round, the trade talks broke down. The principal players turned out to be the EU, the US and the developing world, led by India and China. The US Trade Representative, Ms Susan Schwab, openly expressed her opinion that “a handful of big emerging countries (read India and China) really threaten this round for the rest of us.” On the other side, the Commerce Mini ster, Mr Kamal Nath, put the blame squarely on the US with his rhetoric that he cannot negotiate the livelihood concerns of millions of poor Indian farmers against the commercial interests of the US.
One may ask: Why try again to flog a dead horse, especially now? The US President, Mr George Bush, is on his way out. Moreover, he has lost the so-called fast-track authority under which the President can take a simple ‘yes or no’ vote in the US Congress on a trade Bill, without detailed clause-by-clause ratification.
The US economy and much of the world economy (except the major oil-producing States such as Russia and Saudi Arabia, which are either not members of WTO or are marginal players) is in serious trouble and is in no mood for trade liberalisation.
In India, the Government has narrowly survived the Indo-US nuclear deal. Then, who is interested in restarting the trade talks which could not succeed even under more favourable economic and political conditions? Several answers are possible.
Restarting trade talks
First, it would be even more difficult to strike any complex multilateral WTO trade deal for the new US President in the initial years of his presidency. But if the outgoing President Bush can come close to striking a WTO trade deal, it may be easier for the next President to give some finishing touches and get it through the Congress.
Second, without the constraints imposed by the Left partners of the coalition, the Indian Government may now want to strike a more reformist posture. However, with general elections round the corner, this does not seem very likely — specially if it is a question of reducing tariff barriers on agricultural imports, which affects millions of small farmers.
Third, the long-term costs of failed WTO talks could be substantial. Hence, all efforts should be made to bring about even a minimalist agreement to save WTO as an institution of multilateral trade talks. The other option is bilateral or regional trade agreements which have substantially weakened the multilateral negotiations machinery.
Fourth, there could be a stronger case for negotiated multilateral trade liberalisation agreements when the world economic system is in trouble. In times of recession and job loss, there will be more pressures to revert to protectionism and beggar-thy-neighbour policies.
Chances of progress
So, one should not grudge the efforts or the timing. But, what are the chances of any progress in the future?
It should be noted here that a substantial agreement was reached at Geneva on 18 out of 20 issues put on the table for negotiations. The two contentious issues on which no agreement could be reached were the agricultural subsidies by the developed countries and the Special Products (SP) and the Special Safeguard Mechanism (SSM) for agricultural imports by the developing countries.
The US was willing to cap its trade-distorting agricultural subsidies at $15 billion which is way above its actual level of subsidies in 2006 ($11 billion) and 2007 ($7 billion). Since these were years of unusually high global farm prices and, hence, low levels of subsidy payouts, the US wanted to keep the door open to raise subsidies if agricultural prices plummet in future.
Gaps in negotiating positions
India wanted to put the cap on US subsidies at its current level. On the other hand, it wanted to have the right to hike its (already high) import duties on sensitive agricultural products (SPs) if imports reach 10 per cent of domestic market for such commodities. The US wanted to set the SSM trigger at 40 per cent of imports. Given these wide gaps in the negotiating positions of the two camps on these two issues, the talks had to collapse.
The WTO decision-making relies on consensus and not majority voting of any kind. Hence, if an exception is demanded by a member, no agreement is reached unless the exception is either accommodated or dropped by consensus. This has made WTO negotiations increasingly complex and time-consuming.
It should also be noted that there is a difference in the position taken by US and EU in this connection. The EU is willing to cut back some of its agricultural subsidies provided countries such as India reduce restrictions on imports of industrial products and services. That is easier for India to accept. But the US farm lobby is willing to allow reduction in farm subsidies only if the US agriculture gets additional market access in countries such as India.
Given the livelihood concerns of millions of small farmers and the potential political fallout, it is nearly impossible for the Indian government to liberalise imports in sensitive agricultural products. Thus, the chances of any real breakthrough in Doha talks do not look bright at this moment.
There could still be a breakthrough if the developed countries eventually accept — though grudgingly — the stand of developing countries that though they gave a lot of concessions in the Uruguay Round, the agricultural subsidies in the developed countries have not materially changed (except that some subsidies have been de-linked from production).
So, this time, the developed countries should unilaterally cut farm subsidies without expecting any significant reciprocal reduction in agricultural protection on the part of developing nations.
Areas of (dis)agreement
India has already expressed its willingness to open up more in some service areas such as telecom and financial services provided the developed countries allow additional concessions in the movement of temporary work-related personnel.
The areas of disagreement in the manufacturing sector are mainly over whether the reciprocal tariff reductions would take the form of small cuts on a wide front or larger cuts in some specific sectors, leaving other sensitive areas (like the “infant” automobiles sector for India) unaffected. Such disagreements can be narrowed down with more negotiations.
WTO negotiations do not take place over high moral principles. Ultimately, multilateral trade agreements are the products of hard bargaining. Most countries start with apparently rigid positions which gradually soften after a lot of behind-the-door deal making.
It is clear that no country — especially the poorer and weaker nations — wants the multilateral trade negotiation and dispute settlement mechanism of WTO to break down. In fact, with the signing of more FTAs, the difficulties of enforcement of rules are increasingly coming out in the open.
Even in the US, politicians, including the Democrat Presidential candidate, Mr Barack Obama, are voicing concern over the implications of NAFTA and other FTAs with the neighbouring nations. They want to bring in other issues, such as labour and environmental standards, into the agreements.
In a recent international conference in New Delhi attended by the WTO chief, Mr Pascal Lamy, Mr Kamal Nath and other bigwigs, strong sentiments were expressed against the proliferation of regional trade arrangements. A proposal was mooted that there should be a ‘sunset clause’, setting a time limit on preferential tariffs allowed to members.
At the end of the term, the same preferential tariffs will have to be extended to all WTO members. Regionalism, even if permitted temporarily, will eventually have to give way to multilateralism. Hence, all is not lost yet.
(The author is a former Professor of Economics at IIM Calcutta. Responses to blfeedback@thehindu.co.in)
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/2008/08/27/stories/2008082750480800.htm
Free Imperialism Essays
Internal imperialism.. ---Riv... [tags: essays research papers], 377 words (1.1 pages), Unrated Essays, [preview] · Imperialism in India - Imperialism in ...
www.123helpme.com/search.asp?text=Imperialism - 40k - Cached - Similar pages
Climates and Constitutions: Health, Race, Environment and British ...
western ranchers share many values and challenges, the West’s internal ... Imperialism in India 1600–1850 (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1999. ...
linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0305748801903408 - Similar pages
by D Kennedy - 2001 - All 3 versions
JSTOR: India and British Imperialism
India and British Imperialism. By GORHAM D. SANDERSON. ... But we now have abundant evidence of the internal decay of the Maratha political system and the ...
links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0043-4078(195206)5%3A2%3C300%3AIABI%3E2.0.CO%3B2-8 - Similar pages
by DM Brown
islamic law and western imperialism
If internal struggles shaped Islamic reactions to Western imperialism, ... Chatterjee has argued convincingly that British imperialists in India took up the ...
www.stanford.edu/group/SHR/5-1/text/collier.html - 42k - Cached - Similar pages
Imperialism
Internal Political Pressures: Social Imperialism. The rise of mass electoral politics created ... Lord Curzon, the Viceroy of India put it this way in 1907: ...
www.mtholyoke.edu/courses/rschwart/hist151s05/Imperialism.htm - 13k - Cached - Similar pages
British Imperialism - Research and Read Books, Journals, Articles ...
...argues that the history of British imperialism in India must be viewed...Cromer Ancient and Modern Imperialism . British Rule in India JAWAHARLAL...only ...
www.questia.com/library/sociology-and-anthropology/systems-of-government/imperialism/british-imperialism.jsp - Similar pages
Nationalism India Free Research Papers 1 - 30
The greatest challenge to Indian Nationalism was India's internal divisions . ... Imperialism - In India And China ... Chinese nationalism spread and a ...
www.oppapers.com/topics/nationalism-india/0 - 42k - Cached - Similar pages
RAW: An Instrument Of Indian Imperialism By Isha Khan
13 Oct 2007 ... Ever since the partition of the sub-continent India has been openly meddling in Nepal's internal affairs by contriving internal strife and ...
www.countercurrents.org/khan131007.htm - 37k - Cached - Similar pages
New Imperialism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The transition to formal imperialism in India was effectively accomplished with the transfer of administrative functions from the chartered British East ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Imperialism - 64k - Cached - Similar pages
Did Karl Marx endorse imperialism? « Louis Proyect: The ...
10 May 2006 ... Marx’s views on British imperialism in India did undergo an important ... as well as the internal trade of India, were the monopoly of the ...
louisproyect.wordpress.com/2006/05/10/did-karl-marx-endorse-imperialism/ - 51k - Cached - Similar pages
Naxal Revolution Archives: Singur Tapasi Malik(16 years) - Raped ...
20 Dec 2006 ... Pit where Tapasi Malik’s burning body was found inside the Singur cordoned area.(note- one can see the erected fences) ...
naxalrevolution.blogspot.com/2006/12/singur-tapasi-malik16-years-raped-and.html - 80k - Cached - Similar pages
Who Killed Tapasi Malik At Singur?
NEW and definitive light has been shed on the murder of a young woman named Tapasi Malik. Tapasi was done away brutally nearly five months ago one early ...
pd.cpim.org/2007/0506/05062007_bengal.htm - 13k - Cached - Similar pages
Tapasi Malik case: Charges framed CPM leader-India-The Times of India
Dutta and Malik have been charged by the CBI with conspiracy to murder Tapasi Malik, whose charred body was found close to the Tata Motors factory site at ...
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Tapasi_Malik_case_Charges_framed_CPM_leader/rssarticleshow/2604946.cms - 38k - Cached - Similar pages
CPI(M) lies about Tapasi Malik’s death - apologist Vijay Prasad ...
The brutal rape and murder of Tapasi Malik, the 18 year old girl who was a highly motivated member of the Save Farmland Committee spearheading the struggle ...
sanhati.com/news/307/ - 17k - Cached - Similar pages
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
